Alexander Comstock Kirk

Alexander Comstock Kirk
Born	November 26, 1888 Chicago, Illinois
Died	March 23, 1979 (aged 90) Tucson, Arizona
Nationality	United States

Alexander Comstock Kirk (November 26, 1888 – March 23, 1979) was a United States diplomat.

Early years

Advertisement for Kirk's soap

Alexander Comstock Kirk was born in Chicago, Illinois, on November 26, 1888, the son of James Alexander Kirk (1840–1907)^[1] and Clara Comstock (1851–1936). His family lived in Hartland, Wisconsin.^[2] Their wealth derived from America's largest soap manufacturing concern,^[1] which was founded by Kirk's grandfather in Utica, New York, in 1839, relocated to Chicago in 1860, and capitalized as James S. Kirk & Co. in 1900. James Alexander Kirk was a director of the company.^[3] Its 2 national brands were "American Family" for laundry and "Juvenile" for the bath.^[2][4]

Kirk was "fat" and "unhappy" in childhood and enjoyed drawing. At age 9, he attended the Art Institute of Chicago until his family decided he was too young to be drawing nude models. He was then sent to work incognito in a soap factory until his identity was discovered. He was then tutored at home for half the year by Hughell Fosbroke, future head of the General Theological Seminary of New York, spending the other half traveling in Europe with his mother and sister.^[2]

Kirk attended the University of Chicago for one year and then Yale University, where he excelled in physics^[2] and graduated in 1909.^[5] He appeared with the Yale University Dramatic Association in 1908-09.^[6] Kirk's father died of a heart attack in 1907.^[1]

He next spent 2 years at the School of Political Sciences in Paris.^[2] In order to fulfill his mother's promise to his late father, he earned his law degree from Harvard Law School in 1914.^[7] He was admitted to the Illinois bar. He joined the board of the family business at a salary of $10,000 a year.^[2]

Kirk had two sisters, Gertrude 24 years his senior and Margaret his near contemporary. His sister Margaret married Albert Billings Ruddock in New York's Cathedral of Saint John the Divine in March 1912. The couple left for Berlin following the ceremony. Ruddock was Third Secretary of the American Embassy in Berlin in 1913, when Mrs. Kirk visited the couple there.^[8] In 1954 Ruddock became Chairman of the Board of Trustees of California Institute of Technology, where an undergraduate residence hall was named for him in 1960.^[9]

Diplomatic career

Kirk joined the American Diplomatic Service on March 6, 1915.^[10]

In 1916, he tranferred his post as Secretary of the Embassy in Berlin to position in Constantinople.^[11]

Kirk served as private secretary to the Secretary of State during World War I and accompanied him in that position to the 1919 Paris Peace Conference. He then lived in "a commodious old house in Georgetown with his mother to act as hostess on the occasion of his entertainments," until posted to Peking as Secretary of the Embassy.^[12]

He managed the State Department budget for a time in the 1920s, and later said he thought it "an obligation" to spend the entire amount in order to support the argument for additional appropriations.^[2]

Kirk was Counselor of the U.S. Embassy in Rome in 1932. His mother was presented to Queen Elena of Italy on March 9, 1932.^[13] She lived in Rome during his service there, and Kirk entertained important guests at her home, the Villa Spada on the Janiculum.^[14] Even in 1930, long before rising to ambassadorial rank, he entertained lavishly. He hosted an opera party for Mrs. William Randolph Hearst on her 1930 tour of Europe.^[15]

Kirk was assigned to Moscow as Embassy Counselor and consul general effective March 18, 1938,^[16] where he was the senior official in the 9-month interim between the service of Ambassadors Davies and Steinhardt.^[2][17]

He served as Chargé d'affaires in Berlin beginning in May 1939 and became the senior officer when the American ambassador, Hugh R. Wilson, was recalled to protest the anti-Jewish attacks of Kristallnacht.^[18] Though his status was too low to allow access to important officials in the German government, he communicated with them by staging conversations close to a device the Germans used to eavesdrop on his conversations.^[2] Time called him "adroit" in his "uncomfortable post."^[19] He developed contacts with Germans who opposed the Nazi regime and became convinced, in spite of Germany's early victories, that the war would end badly for Germany. Discussing with noted dissident Helmuth James von Moltke the need for Germany to suffer complete defeat with no one to blame but its Nazi leaders, he said: "Do you want to know my solution? It's a flood without an ark."^[20] During the war, in 1943, Moltke twice tried without success to contact Kirk, whom he trusted as an intermediary between the German opposition and the Allies.^[21]

Kirk served briefly as Embassy Counselor in Rome before becoming Minister to Egypt in 1941,^[22] when Time magazine described him as "smooth, spare."^[23]

From March 29, 1941, to March 29, 1944, Kirk served as Ambassador to Egypt, first as head of the U.S. Legation and then of the Embassy. He advised the State Department in 1941 that a Jewish state "is incapable of realization in the future unless imposed by force on an unwilling native population." Under Secretary of State Sumner Welles did not share his assessment and did not forward Kirk's views to the White House.^[24] Drawing on his experience with Nazi propaganda and antisemitism in Germany, Kirk expanded the embassy's coverage of Arabic-language broadcasts, providing complete translations of what came to be known as the "Axis Broadcasts in Arabic" along with his weekly analysis from 1941 to 1944, which Hull circulated widely. He dissected the Nazi's manipulation of anti-colonial, anti-Jewish, and anti-Bolshevik sentiment and their charges that Roosevelt and Churchill were being manipulated by their Jewish supporters.^[25] At the beginning of his Cairo tenure, Kirk focused on the strategic necessity of Allied victory in the Middle East because it would be impossible to counter the Nazi's exploitation of an Axis victory in its propaganda. Once the Allies won control of the region, he stressed political analysis and repeatedly underscored the critical role of the Egyptian capital in Arab nationalism.^[26] As Kirk looked to the end of the war, he anticipated a post-colonial world in which nations operated freely in a free enterprise environment, unlike Secretary of State Cordell Hull who expected the persistence of traditional spheres of influence, notably that of Great Britain in Egypt.^[27] While posted to Cairo, Kirk kept one house in the city for lunch, another near the pyramids for dinner and sleeping, and a houseboat on the Nile. He hosted FDR, Churchill, and Chiang Kai-shek at the second house for the November 1943 Cairo Conference.^[2] He has been described as "an archeological dilettante" who liked to lecture his guests as they gazed at the pyramids. Clare Boothe Luce claimed to have flummoxed him by pre-empting his performance by asking: "Mr. Ambassador, what are those strange-looking objects?"^[28]

Along with several military men Kirk devised the successful plan to attack Rommel's communications instead of his ground forces.^[2] He later received the United States of America Typhus Commission Medal for his support of the Commission's work during his time in Egypt.^[29]

While resident in Cairo, Kirk was also accredited to the government-in-exile of Greece until November 13, 1941, and to Saudi Arabia until July 18, 1943.

Kirk was appointed U.S. representative on the Allied Advisory Council for Italy, with the rank of ambassador, on April 4, 1944.^[30] He was appointed Ambassador to Italy on November 30, 1944,^[31] and in January 1945 became the first ambassador of any country to present his credentials to the new Italian government.^[32] Upon his appointment, Time gave him the title "suave Career Man."^[33] He resigned in 1946. When the American Office of War Information produced an Italian-language publication, Kirk insisted it be labeled propaganda to maintain a clear distinction between what Italians were accomplishing for themselves or not.^[2]

In August 1945, he received petitions from Russian prisoners of war, taken by the Germans and liberated by Allied forces. They wrote to him in his role as Political Advisor to Supreme Headquarters Allied Expeditionary Force (SHAEF) and claimed the status of "political refugees" and asked "in the name of humanity" not to be repatriated to the Soviet Union. Kirk wrote to Secretary of State Byrnes seeking guidance, a diplomatic way of expressing his reservations about the repatriation policy. He was instructed to make certain none of the prisoners was actually from Poland or the Baltic States and to proceed with the repatriations.^[34]

Kirk was long famous for entertaining and continued even when forced to operate in Rome "under a wartime minimum." Six or eight guests joined him for lunch or dinner, often many more. One Friday lunch he hosted about 20 enlisted men. Though some involved in recruiting the guests worried that a Negro corporal might not be well received, Kirk gave him the place of honor on his right.^[2]

Life described him near the end of his career: "To call Kirk an ornament of the State Department is almost a libelous understatement....Kirk's true value resides in the fact that he is an American who, far from being an innocent abroad, knows Europe infinitely better than most Europeans. This makes him almost unique in the current roster of U.S. foreign representatives in the diplomatic, charitable, or didactic spheres. Kirk's career should be studied in detail, like The Education of Henry Adams."^[2] Fortune in July 1946 called him "foppish, intelligent, and very rich."^[35]

Kirk predicted in 1945 that future diplomats should be technical experts "chosen for the ability not only to diagnose economic, industrial and political trends, but also to adjust their dislocations before they can start wars." He lamented the willingness of governments to spend on wars far more than on the diplomacy that might prevent them.^[2]

A few years after Kirk's retirement, as Senator Joseph McCarthy launched a campaign against suspected homosexuals in government, one investigator's 1948 report charged that State Department employees Carmel Offie and Charles W. Thayer "were very close personal friends of former Ambassador Alexander Kirk who is not now in the service but who had a very bad reputation of being a homosexual and certainly protected a lot of homosexual people."^[36]

Personal life

In the 1920s, when he was Counselor to the American Embassy in Rome, Kirk remodeled a significant building in Georgetown, the Robinson house, at the corner of Wisconsin Avenue and R Street and "filled it with furniture, rugs, hangings and objects of art brought from the Orient."^[37] In 1942 he sold this estate, including its "elaborate formal gardens, outsize ballroom, marble-floored billiard room, and swimming pool," to Evalyn Walsh McLean, mining heiress and owner of the Hope Diamond.^[38]

While posted to Berlin, he lived in an "enormous mansion" in the "swank" Grunewald neighborhood.^[39] One German who visited described it as "one vast hall after another, and he quiet alone in the midst of it. Very funny; a little like the theatre." His staff of servants spoke only Italian.^[40] He held "a large buffet luncheon every Sunday noon, as a means of revenging himself for such hospitality as his position required him to accept."^[39]

Façade of Palazzo Barberini

While Ambassador in Rome, Kirk lived in the Barberini palace, which he redecorated. He filled a large enclosure the size of a tennis court with "Renaissance tables and settees covered in ivory silk," according to Life magazine, to create what he termed "a sort of cozy sitting room."^[2] When Life profiled him in 1945, it reported that he had always established fine residences wherever he was posted: "The Ambassador is fond of houses, and especially big ones. Equipped with ample private funds and the courage of his complexes, Kirk sees no reason why he should not capitalize the chance his profession gives him to indulge this fondness, all the more since such indulgence usually works out to the benefit of the State Department in one way or another."^[2] His nickname around this time was "Buffy."^[41]

In 1945 he attributed "his excellent health to the fact that he has never worn himself down by any form of exercise more violent than scratching, which he only does when suffering from insomnia at 6 a.m."^[2]

He planned to retire to Arizona and bought a piece of land in the White Mountains at the end of World War II. He joked that he would live there not in a house but in a cave.^[2] Another diplomat reported that he retired to the mountains of Colorado and "amused himself operating a ranch and raising cattle" for a few years before relocating to Texas.^[17]

His sister Gertrude Kirk Metzeroff died in St. Petersburg, Florida in 1948 at the age of 84. According to her obituary, her brother Alexander was then living in Washington, D.C., and Santa Barbara, California, while her sister Margaret was living in Santa Barbara.^[42]

Kirk died in Tucson, Arizona, on March 23, 1979. He is buried with his mother in Rome's Protestant Cemetery (Cimitero Acattolico).^[43]

In his 1967 memoirs, George F. Kennan sketched an affectionate portrait of Kirk, as he knew him in Berlin before America entered World War II: "a confirmed bachelor, profoundly saddened by the recent death of an adored mother who, while she was alive, had preempted much of both his companionship and his emotional life, Kirk drowned the inner emptiness in the performance of his arduous official duties," sleeping in an office alcove while working 16 to 18 hours daily.^[44] He continued:^[45]

He was a carryover from an older day when to be rich entitled you to be eccentric, and he made the most of the privilege....

Deliberately, I think, as a gesture of defiance and self-protection, and in the indulgence of a fine sense of the theatrical, Kirk worked at giving himself the aspect of exactly that sort of American career diplomat of which the American philistine has always been the most suspicious: elegant, overrefined, haughty, and remote. It was a manner of enlivening life by playing the buffoon....His understanding was intuitive rather than analytical. His conversation consisted largely of weary, allusive quips. His posing sometimes went so far as to raise doubts whether he was serious.

But behind this facade of urbane and even exaggerated sophistication there lay a great intuitive shrewdness and a devastating critical sense of humor, directed to himself as well as others. No one impressed him....He despised the Nazis and held them at arm's length with barbed irony....

The only thing worth living for, he once told me, was good form. He himself had little to live for; there were moments when he would have liked to leave this life; but suicide would be an abrupt act, and abruptness was the height of bad form....He disclaimed all further interest in the Foreign Service, since his mother's death. He had entered it, he solemnly maintained, only to spare her having her bags inspected at frontiers. But he could not just resign, especially in wartime; that would have been abrupt....

After service as Ambassador in Egypt and Italy, he sidled, quietly and unobserved, out of all of our lives.

Kirk claimed he escaped from diplomatic functions by whatever ruse the situation required. At one embassy in Rome he found it necessary to leave by a door he could only reach by going under a grand piano. "In a case of this sort, Kirk recommends slow motion, which, he says, often prevents witnesses from even noticing a maneuver which, if executed fast, might horrify them."^[2]

He insisted his favorite color was gray. He never had fresh flowers, rather he collected artificial ones in his favorite color. His wardrobe and household were maintained by a servant named Mario, who joined the Kirk household in Mexico early in Kirk's career and continued through his stint as Ambassador in Rome.^[2]

Notes

1. Chicago Historical Society, Charter, Constitution, By-laws, Membership List, Annual Report (1903), 286, available online, accessed January 25, 2011. James Alexander Kirk was a Chicago Alderman in 1876-7 and influential in the creation of the city's paid Fire Department following the Great Chicago Fire of 1871.
2. Life: Noel F. Busch, "Alexander Kirk," August 13, 1945, accessed January 23, 2011
3. Chicago Securities (Chicago Directory Company, 1903), 234-5, available online, accessed January 25, 2011
4. Kennan, 113-4, asked rhetorically in 1967: "who of my age could forget the 'Kirk's soap' of the advertisements of our boyhood?"
5. Yale University: Catalogue of the Officers and Graduates of Yale University in New Haven, 1701-1910 (New Haven: Tuttle, Morehouse & Taylor, 1910), 236, accessed January 23, 2011
6. Richard Brinsley Sheridan, The Critic or A Tragedy Rehearsed (New Haven, CT: Yale University Dramatic Association, 1908), xix-xx; New York Times: "Yale Men Score in Old Comedies," January 5, 1909, accessed January 23, 2011
7. Harvard University: Quinquennial Catalogue of the Officers and Graduates, 1636-1915 (Harvard University Press, 1915), 785, accessed January 23, 2011
8. New York Times: "City Social Notes," March 17, 1912, accessed January 25, 2011; New York Times: "American Tourists Still Crowd Berlin," July 27, 1913, accessed January 25, 2011, where the relationship is mistaken called daughter-in-law rather than daughter; New York Times: "Germany Holds American Crowds," August 3, 1913, accessed January 25, 2011. On Ruddock see also Frederic William Wile, The Assault: Germany before the Outbreak and England in War-time; A Personal Narrative (Indianapolis: Bobbs-Merrill, 1916), 107, available online, accessed January 25, 2011
9. The California Tech: "Tech trustees pick Ruddock," November 4, 1954, accessed January 28, 2011. Ruddock;s State Department service lasted until 1923. He joined the Board of Trustees in 1938.
10. Foreign Service List, 1939, 65. The Diplomatic Service later became the Foreign Service.
11. New York Times: Berlin Post for Harriman," March 2, 1916, accessed January 24, 2011
12. New York Times: "Social Notes," April 1, 1920, accessed January 24, 2011
13. New York Times: "Queen Sees Ten Americans," March 10, 1932, accessed January 25, 2011
14. Henry Rushton Fairclough, Warming Both Hands: The Autobiography of Henry Rushton Fairclough (Stanford University Press, 1941), 506. Kirk was First Secretary at the time of Fairclough's visit.
15. TIME: Italy: Publisher's Wife Abroad," March 17, 1930, accessed January 23, 2011
16. New York Times: Alexander Kirk Named Counselor at Moscow," March 29, 1938, accessed January 23, 2011; Foreign Service List, 1939, 28
17. George W. Baer, A Question of Trust, The Origins of U.S.-Soviet Diplomatic Relations: The Memoirs of Loy. W, Henderson (Stanford, CA: Hoover Institution Press, 1986), 313. "In my opinion," wrote Loy W. Henderson, "the embassy never functioned better than it did during the nine months that he was in charge of it."
18. "Kirk, Home, Silent on Rome Mission". New York Times. October 19, 1940. Retrieved May 8, 2013. The appointment was effective April 13, 1939, Foreign Service List, 1940, 75; Baer, 313
19. TIME: Foreign Relations: Leg-Men," July 1, 1940, accessed January 23, 2011
20. Helmuth James von Moltke, Letters to Freya (NY: Alfred A. Knopf, 1990), 14-5, 70, 82, 111, 115n. Moltke was a civilian legal aide to the German general staff.
21. Motlke, 317n, 372n
22. New York Times: "Nelson and Landis Reach Cairo by Air," October 6, 1943, accessed January 23, 2011; Foreign Service List, 1942, 10
23. TIME: Foreign Relations: Winant to London," February 17, 1941, accessed January 23, 2011
24. Lawrence Davidson, "Review: Sympathy for Jewish Statehood," in Journal of Palestine Studies, vol. 15, no. 1, Autumn 1985, 134
25. Jeffrey Herf, Nazi Propaganda for the Arab World (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2009), 10–1, 72–3, 86, 97–9, 101–2, 106, 217
26. Herf, Nazi Propaganda for the Arab World, 70–1, 127, 140–1
27. Nancy E. Gallagher, "Anglo-American Rivalry and the Establishment of a Medical Research Institute in Egypt, 1942-1948," in International History Review, vol. 9, no. 2, May 1987, 292; Barry Rubin, "Anglo-American Relations in Saudi Arabia, 1941-45," in Journal of Contemporary History, vol. 14, no. 2, April 1979, 255
28. Stephen Shadegg, Claire Boothe Luce (NY: Simon & Schuster, 1970), 149
29. "Ambassadors Helped in Fight to Check Typhus," in The Science News-Letter, vol. 47, no. 6, February 10, 1945, 85
30. "Chronology," in Bulletin of International News,vol. 21, no. 8, April 15, 1944, 328; the appointment was effective March 30, 1944, Foreign Service List, 1945, 53
31. "Chronology", in Bulletin of International News, vol. 21, no. 25, December 9, 1944, 1081-2; the effective date of the appointment was December 8, 1944, Foreign Service List, 1945, 27
32. New York Times: "Kirk Offers Credentials," January 9, 1945, accessed January 23, 2011
33. TIME: "U.S. at War: Work Done," December 18, 1944, accessed January 23, 2011
34. Cathal J. Nolan, "Americans in the Gulag: Detention of US Citizens by Russia and the Onset of the Cold War, 1944-49," in Journal of Contemporary History, vol. 25, no. 4, October 1990, 532-3
35. John Lamberton Harper, America and the Reconstruction of Italy, 1945-1948 (Cambridge University Press, 2002), 17, 171n33, available online, accessed August 29, 2014
36. Robert D. Dean, Imperial Brotherhood: Gender and the Making of Cold War Foreign Policy (Amherst, MA: University of Massachusetts Press, 2001), 106
37. New York Times: Richard V. Oulahan, "Georgetown Holds Old-Time Prestige," December 25, 1927, accessed January 24, 2011; New York Times: Richard V. Oulahan, "Georgetown House of History Bought," May 19, 1929, accessed January 24, 2011
38. TIME: "People, Jan. 26, 1942", accessed January 23, 2011. For a brief history of the property, see Grace Dunlop Peter, A Portrait of Old George Town (Richmond, Dietz Press, 1951), 298-9, available online, accessed January 25, 2011
39. George F. Kennan, Memoirs, 1925-1950 (Boston: Little, Brown, 1967), 113
40. Moltke, 29n
41. Robert P. Newman, The Cold War Romance of Lillian Hellman and John Melby (University of North Carolina Press, 1989), 77
42. St. Petersburg Times: "Mrs. Metzeroff, Here 12 Years, Dies at Age 84," August 5, 1948, accessed January 26, 2011
43. Academia di Danimarca: Stone 1450, accessed March 24, 2012
44. Kennan, 112
45. Kennan, 113-5