Richard Harding Poff

Richard Harding Poff
Justice of the Supreme Court of Virginia
In office August 31, 1972 – December 31, 1988
Appointed by	Linwood Holton
Preceded by	Thomas Gordon
Succeeded by	Elizabeth Lacy
Member of the U.S. House of Representatives from Virginia's 6th district
In office January 3, 1953 – August 29, 1972
Preceded by	Clarence Burton
Succeeded by	Caldwell Butler
Personal details
Born	October 19, 1923 Radford, Virginia, U.S.
Died	June 27, 2011 (aged 87) Tullahoma, Tennessee, U.S.
Political party	Republican
Alma mater	Roanoke College University of Virginia
Military service
Allegiance	United States
Service/branch	United States Army
Years of service	1943–1945
Rank	First lieutenant
Unit	U.S. Army Air Forces  • Eighth Air Force
Battles/wars	World War II
Awards	Distinguished Flying Cross

Richard Harding Poff (October 19, 1923 – June 27, 2011) was an American politician and judge. He was first elected to the United States House of Representatives in 1952 from Virginia's 6th congressional district.^[1] An attorney and a Republican, he was given strong consideration for the United States Supreme Court by President Richard M. Nixon and was later appointed as a Justice (later Senior Justice) of the Virginia Supreme Court.

Education

Poff did his undergraduate work at Roanoke College in Salem, Virginia, and gained his LL.B. in 1948 from the University of Virginia School of Law at Charlottesville.

Military service

During the Second World War, Poff served as a bomber pilot with the Eighth Air Force in England; flew thirty-five successful missions over Europe; awarded the Distinguished Flying Cross; was inactivated from the service as a first lieutenant serving from February 1943 to August 1945.

Legislative career

Poff was first elected to Congress in 1952, defeating incumbent Democrat Clarence G. Burton. He was the first Republican to represent this part of Virginia since Reconstruction, and likely owed his victory to Dwight Eisenhower carrying the state in that year's presidential election. However, the 6th had already been moving away from its Democratic roots for some time. The Byrd Democrats in western Virginia and the Shenandoah Valley had begun splitting their tickets as early as the 1930s.

Poff had his share of controversy during his decades in the House of Representatives. He was one of only two Republicans, along with the rest of Virginia's entire Congressional delegation, and nearly all members from Southern states, to sign the Southern Manifesto protesting the Supreme Court's mandate in Brown v. Board of Education to desegregate public schools. A. Linwood Holton, former Governor of Virginia (1970–1974), and the commonwealth's first post-Reconstruction Republican Governor, suggests that Poff probably could not have been reelected unless he signed the manifesto.^[2] Despite that controversial decision, he was well liked by most of his constituents, most of whom had never been represented by a Republican before. This included many African Americans, who in an ABC News report on his nomination to the U.S. Supreme Court described him as having a great interest in individuals; only one person in that report described him as a racist despite his having signed the Southern Manifesto. Consistent with his signing of the Manifesto, he also opposed all civil rights measures in the 1960s with the exception of the 24th Amendment. In 1971, he favored the Equal Employment Opportunity Act and supported federal aid to accelerate the desegregation process. He was the only member of the House Republican leadership who did not support President Eisenhower's proposal to increase the minimum wage and widen its coverage. According to John Dean, he was also the author of most of the 25th Amendment to the Constitution of the United States while serving on the Judiciary Committee of the U.S. House of Representatives.^[3]

Electoral history

• 1952; Poff was elected to the U.S House of Representatives with 51.55% of the vote, defeating Democrat Clarence Godber Burton.
• 1954; Poff was re-elected with 62.31% of the vote, defeating Democrat Ernest Robertson and Social Democrat J.B. Brayman.
• 1956; Poff was re-elected with 62.09% of the vote, defeating Democrat John L. Whitehead and Social Democrat Brayman.
• 1958; Poff was re-elected with 56.74% of the vote, defeating Democrat Richard F. Pence and Social Democrat Brayman.
• 1960; Poff was re-elected with 82.62% of the vote, defeating Social Democrat Brayman.
• 1962; Poff was re-elected with 65.22% of the vote, defeating Democrat John P. Wheeler and now-Independent Brayman.
• 1964; Poff was re-elected with 56.24% of the vote, defeating Democrat William B. Hopkins.
• 1966; Poff was re-elected with 80.84% of the vote, defeating Democrat Murray A. Stoller.
• 1968; Poff was re-elected with 92.16% of the vote, defeating Democrat Tom Hufford.
• 1970; Poff was re-elected with 74.58% of the vote, defeating Democrat Roy R. White.

Nomination to Supreme Court of the United States

Before President Richard Nixon could formally nominate him for the U.S. Supreme Court, Poff withdrew (before nomination reached the Senate). John Dean wrote that Poff actually made that decision based on concerns that he would thus be forced to reveal to his then-12-year-old son that he had been adopted. Poff's concern was that the child would be negatively affected by that kind of information if revealed before he was old enough to understand.^{[4] [5]} Nevertheless, according to the New York Times, within weeks after he withdrew from consideration that sensitive personal information was revealed in Jack Anderson's column, and he was forced to inform the child of his adoption anyway. ^[6] By then, it was too late for reconsideration, and eventually Lewis Powell, another Virginian, was confirmed to the Supreme Court in Poff's place.

In 1971, when under consideration for the Supreme Court, Poff said in a newspaper interview that he had supported the Southern Manifesto and opposed desegregation because he believed he would have otherwise been defeated for reelection to the U.S. House. He voiced regret over his opposition to past civil rights measures. Within a year of those comments, he resigned from the House to join the Virginia Supreme Court.^[7]

Legislation

Poff is also well known as one of the men who, as a member of the House Judiciary Committee, sponsored the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act, better known as RICO. Poff had an interesting take on RICO, which has since been ignored by the Supreme Court. Poff stated in the Congressional Record that the Act should be used only against organizations, and not individuals.

Supreme Court of Virginia

Richard H. Poff went on to become Justice and then a Senior Justice of the Virginia Supreme Court, where he served until his retirement.

He died on June 27, 2011, in a life care center in Tullahoma, Tennessee.^[8][9]

Legacy

The Richard H. Poff Federal Building in Roanoke, Virginia is named for Poff. It houses many of the primary federal offices in southwest Virginia, including the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Virginia and the Internal Revenue Service.

References

1. "Official Congressional Biography". bioguide.congress.gov. Retrieved 2010-12-02.
2. Holton, Linwood (1999-07-16). "Gov. Holton's Keynote Address". Virginia Governors Project. Center for Politics at the University of Virginia. Retrieved 2007-01-08. He likely would have been defeated if he had not signed that document, but I expect he has regretted that signature through the years.
3. Conley, Richard S.; Richard M. Yon. "Legislative Liaison, White House Roll-Call Predictions, and Divided Government: The Eisenhower Experience, 83rd–84th Congresses" (PDF). University of Florida Department of Political Science. Retrieved 2007-01-08. ...[When] the President called for an increase in the minimum wage ... all members of the GOP leadership save Poff of Virginia came on board.
4. Dean, John (2002) [2001]. The Rehnquist Choice: The Untold Story of the Nixon Appointment That Redefined the Supreme Court. New York: Touchstone. p. 119. ISBN 0-7432-2607-0.
5. Ellis, Kate. "Interview with John Dean". The President Calling. American RadioWorks. Retrieved 2007-01-08. Poff ... didn't really want to put himself or his family through the controversy of being nominated and then beat up through the senate confirmation process.
6. ROSEN, JEFFREY (2001-11-04). "Renchburg's the One!". Book Review. New York Times. Retrieved 2007-01-08. ...Representative Richard Poff, a moderate conservative from Virginia...
7. Paul Vitello, "Ex-Supreme Court Pick Dies," Laredo Morning Times, July 2, 2011, p. 11A
8. Paul Vitello (July 1, 2011). "Richard H. Poff, Who Withdrew Court Bid, Dies at 87". The New York Times.
9. "Kilgore Funeral Home Obituary of Richard H. Poff". www.kilgorefuneralhometullahoma.com. Retrieved 2011-06-29.

External sources

• "Congressman Poff Speaks to Students During Independence Day Observance" (jpg). Grapurchat Vol XXXIII Nbr 18. Radford College, Woman's Division of V.P.I. 1954-07-09. p. 1. Retrieved 2007-01-08.