Issai Schur

Issai Schur
Born	January 10, 1875 Mogilev, Russian Empire
Died	January 10, 1941 (aged 66) Tel Aviv, Mandatory Palestine
Residence	Germany
Fields	Mathematics
Doctoral advisor	Georg Frobenius Lazarus Fuchs
Doctoral students	Richard Brauer Robert Frucht Maximilian Herzberger Eberhard Hopf Bernhard Neumann Rose Peltesohn Heinz Prüfer Richard Rado Isaac Jacob Schoenberg Arnold Scholz Wilhelm Specht Karl Dörge

Issai Schur (January 10, 1875 – January 10, 1941) was a mathematician who worked in Germany for most of his life. He studied at Berlin. He obtained his doctorate in 1901, became lecturer in 1903 and, after a stay at Bonn, professor in 1919.

As a student of Frobenius, he worked on group representations (the subject with which he is most closely associated), but also in combinatorics and number theory and even theoretical physics. He is perhaps best known today for his result on the existence of the Schur decomposition and for his work on group representations (Schur's lemma).

Schur published under the name of both I. Schur, and J. Schur, the latter especially in Journal für die reine und angewandte Mathematik. This has led to some confusion.^[1]

Childhood

Issai Schur was the son of the businessman Moses Schur and his wife Golde Schur (née Landau). He was born in Mogilev on the Dnieper River in what was then the Russian Empire. Schur used the name Schaia rather than Issai up in his middle twenties.^[2] Schur's father may have been a wholesale merchant.^[3]

In 1888, at the age of 13, Schur went to Liepāja ( Courland, now in Latvia), where his married sister and his brother lived, 640 km north-west of Mogilev. Kurland was one of the three Baltic governorates of Tsarist Russia, and since the Middle Ages the Baltic Germans were the trend-setting social class.^[4][5] The local Jewish community spoke mostly German and not Yiddish.^[6]

Schur attended the German-speaking Nicolai Gymnasium in Libau from 1888-1894 and reached the top grade in his final examination, and received a gold medal.^[7] Here he became fluent in German.

Education

In October 1894, Schur attended the University of Berlin in mathematics and physics. In 1901, he graduated summa cum laude under Ferdinand Georg Frobenius and Lazarus Immanuel Fuchs with his dissertation On a class of matrices that can be assigned to a given matrix,^[8] which contains a general theory of the representation of linear groups. According to Vogt,^[9] he began to use the name Issai at this time. Schur thought that his chance of success in the Russian Empire was rather poor,^[10] and because he spoke German so perfectly, he remained in Berlin. He graduated in 1903 and was a lecturer at the University of Berlin. Schur held a position as professor at the Berlin University for the ten years from 1903 to 1913.^[11]

In 1913 he accepted an appointment as associate professor and successor of Felix Hausdorff in Bonn. In the following years Frobenius tried various ways to get Schur back to Berlin. Among other things, Schur's name was mentioned in a letter dated June 27, 1913^[12] from Frobenius to Robert Gnehm (the School Board President of the ETH) as a possible successor to Carl Friedrich Geiser.^[13] Frobenius complained that they had never followed his advice before and then said: "That is why I can't even recommend Prof. J. Schur (now in Bonn) to you. He's too good for Zurich, and should be my successor in Berlin". Hermann Weyl got the job in Zurich. The efforts of Frobenius were finally successful in 1916, when Schur succeeded Johannes Knoblauch as adjunct professor. Frobenius died a year later, on August 3, 1917. Schur and Carathéodory were both named as the frontrunners for his successor. But they chose Constantin Carathéodory in the end. In 1919 Schur finally received a personal professorship, and in 1921 he took over the chair of the retired Friedrich Hermann Schottky. In 1922, he was also added to the Prussian Academy of Sciences.

During the time of National Socialism

After the takeover by the National Socialists and the elimination of the parliamentary opposition, the Law for the Restoration of the Professional Civil Service on 7 April 1933, prescribed the release of all distinguished public servants that held unpopular political opinions or who were "Jewish" in origin; a subsequent regulation^[14] extended this to professors and therefore also to Schur. Schur was suspended and excluded from the university system. His colleague Erhard Schmidt fought for his reinstatement, and since Schur had been a Prussian official before the First World War,^[15] he was allowed to participate in certain special lectures on teaching in the winter semester of 1933/1934 again. Schur withdrew his application for leave from the Science Minister and passed up the offer of a visiting professorship at the University of Wisconsin-Madison for the academic year 1933-34.^[16] One element that likely played a role in the rejection of the offer was that Schur no longer felt he could cope with the requirements that would have come with a new beginning in an English-speaking environment.^[17]

Already in 1932, Schur's daughter Hilde had married the doctor Chaim Abelin in Bern.^[18] As a result, Issai Schur visited his daughter in Bern several times. In Zurich he met often with George Pólya, with whom he was on friendly terms since before the First World War.^[19]

On such a trip to Switzerland in the summer of 1935, a letter reached Schur from Ludwig Bieberbach signed on behalf of the Rector's, stating that Schur should urgently seek him out in the University of Berlin.^[20] They needed to discuss an important matter with him. It involved Schur's dismissal on September 30, 1935.^[21]

Although Schur remained a member of the Prussian Academy of Sciences after his release as a professor, but a little later he lost this last remnant of his official position. Due to an intervention from Bieberbach in the spring of 1938 he was forced to explain his resignation from the commission of the Academy.^[22] His membership in the Advisory Board of the Mathematical Journal was ended in early 1939.^[23]

Emigration

Schur's grave at Trumpeldor Cemetery

Schur found himself lonely after the flight of many of his students and the expulsion of renowned scientists from his previous place of work. Only Dr. Helmut Grunsky had been friendly to him, as Schur reported in the late thirties to his expatriate student Max Menachem Schiffer.^[24] The Gestapo was everywhere. Since Schur had announced to his wife his intentions to commit suicide in case of a summons to the Gestapo,^[25] in the summer of 1938 his wife took his letters, and with them a summons from the Gestapo, sent Issai Schur to a relaxing stay in a home outside of Berlin and went with medical certificate allowing her to meet the Gestapo in place of her husband. There they flatly asked why they were still staying in Germany. But there were economic obstacles to the planned emigration : Emigrating Germans had a pre-departure Reich Flight Tax to pay, which was a quarter of their assets. Now Schur's wife had inherited a mortgage on a house in Lithuania, which because of the Lithuanian foreign exchange determination could not be repaid. On the other hand, Schur was forbidden to default or leave the mortgage to the German Reich. Thus the Schurs lacked cash and cash equivalents. Finally, the missing sum of money was somehow supplied, and to this day it does not seem to be clear who were the donors.

Schur was able to leave Germany in early 1939.^[26] His health, however, was already severely compromised. He traveled in the company of a nurse to his daughter in Bern, where his wife also followed a few days later. There they remained for several weeks and then emigrated to Palestine. Only two years later, on his 66th birthday, on January 10, 1941, he died in Tel Aviv of a heart attack.

Work

Schur continued the work of his teacher Frobenius with many important works for group theory and representation theory. In addition, he published important results and elegant proofs of known results in almost all branches of classical algebra and number theory. His collected works^[27] are an impressive proof of this. There, his work on the theory of integral equations and infinite series can be found.

Linear groups

In his doctoral thesis Über eine Klasse von Matrizen, die sich einer gegebenen Matrix zuordnen lassen Issai Schur determined the polynomial representations of the general linear group $GL(n, \mathbb{C})$ on the field $\mathbb {C}$ of complex numbers. The results and methods of this work are still relevant today.^[28] In his book, JA Green determined the polynomial representations of $GL (n, \mathbb{K})$ over infinite fields $\mathbb {K}$ with arbitrary characteristic.^[29] It is mainly based on Schur's dissertation. JA Green writes, "This remarkable work (of Schur) contained many very original ideas, developed with superb algebraic skill. Schur showed that these (polynomial) representations are completely reducible, that each one is "homogeneous" of some degree $r \geq 0$, and that es equivalence types of irreducible polynomial representations of $GL_{n}(\mathbb {C} )$, of fixed homogeneous degree $r$, are in one-to-one correspondence with the partitions $\lambda = (\lambda_1, \ldots, \lambda_n)$ of $r$ into not more than $n$ parts. Moreover, Schur showed that the character of an irreducible representation of type $\lambda$ is given by a certain symmetric function ${\underline{S}}_{\lambda}$ in $n$ variables, since described as a Schur function. According to Green, the methods of Schur's dissertation today are important for the theory of algebraic groups.

In 1927 Schur, in his work On the rational representations of the general linear group, gave new proofs for the main results of his dissertation. If $V$ is the natural $n$-dimensional $\mathbb {C}$ vector space on which $GL(n, \mathbb{C})$ operates, and if $r$ is a natural number, then the $r$-fold tensor product $V^{\otimes r}$ over $\mathbb {C}$ is a $GL(n, \mathbb {C})$-module, on which the symmetric group $S_r$ of degree $r$ also operates by permutation of the tensor factors of each generator $v_1 \otimes \ldots \otimes v_r$ of $V^{\otimes r}$. By exploiting these $S_r - GL(n, \mathbb{C})$-bimodule actions on $V^{\otimes r}$, Schur manages to find elegant proofs of his sentences. This work of Schur was once very well known.

Professorship in Berlin

Schur lived in Berlin as a highly respected member of the academic world, an apolitical scholar. A leading mathematician and outstanding and very successful teacher, he held a prestigious chair at the University of Berlin for 16 years.^[30] Until 1933, his research group had an excellent reputation at the University of Berlin in Germany and beyond. With Schur in the center, his faculty worked with representation theory, which was extended by his students in different directions (including solvable groups, combinatorics, matrix theory).^[31] Schur made fundamental contributions to algebra and group theory which, according to Hermann Weyl, were comparable in scope and depth to those of Emmy Amalie Noether (1882–1935).^[32]

When Schur's lectures were canceled in 1933, there was an outcry among the students and professors who appreciated him and liked him.^[33] By the efforts of his colleagues Erhard Schmidt Schur was allowed to continue lecturing until the end of September 1935 for the time being.^[34] Schur was the last Jewish professor who lost his job at this time.^[35]

Zurich lecture

In Switzerland, Schur's colleagues Heinz Hopf and George Pólya were informed of the dismissal of Issai Schur in 1935. They tried to help as best they could.^[36] On behalf of the Mathematical Seminars chief Michel Plancherel, on December 12, 1935^[37] the school board president Arthur Rohn invited Isay Schur to une série de conférences sur la théorie de la représentation des groupes finis. At the same time he asked that the formal invitation should come from President Rohn, comme le prof. Schur doit obtenir l'autorisation du ministère compétent de donner ces conférences. George Pólya arranged from this invitation of the Mathematical Seminars the Conference of the Department of Mathematics and Physics on December 16.^[38] Meanwhile, on 14 December the official invitation letter from President Rohn had already been dispatched to Issai Schur.^[39] Schur was promised for his guest lecture a fee of CHF 500.

Schur did not reply until January 28, 1936, on which day he was first in the possession of the required approval of the local authority.^[40] He declared himself willing to accept the invitation. He envisaged beginning the lecture on 4 February.^[41] Schur spent most of the month of February in Switzerland. Before his return to Germany he visited his daughter in Bern for a few days, and on 27 February he returned via Karlsruhe, where his sister lived, to Berlin. In a letter to Pólya from Berne, he concludes with the words: From Switzerland I take farewell with a heavy heart.^[42]

In Berlin, meanwhile, Ludwig Bieberbach, in a letter dated February 20, 1936, informed the Reich Minister for Science, Art, and Education on the journey of Schur, and announced that he wanted to find out what was the content of the lecture in Zurich.^[43]

Significant students

Schur had a total of 26^[44] graduate students, some of whom reached mathematical reputation. Among them are

• Alfred Brauer, University of Berlin (1928)
• Richard Brauer, University of Berlin (1925)
• Karl Dörge, University of Berlin (1925)
• Bernhard Neumann, University of Berlin, Cambridge University (1932, 1935)
• Heinz Pruefer, University of Berlin, (1921)
• Richard Rado, University of Berlin, Cambridge University (1933, 1935)
• Isaac Jacob Schoenberg, Alexandru Ioan Cuza University of Iaşi (1926)
• Wilhelm Specht, University of Berlin (1932)
• Helmut Wielandt, University of Berlin (1935)

Legacy

Concepts named after Schur

Among others, the following concepts are named after Issai Schur:

• List of things named after Issai Schur
• Schur algebra
• Schur complement
• Schur index
• Schur indicator
• Schur multiplier
• Schur orthogonality relations
• Schur polynomial
• Schur product
• Schur test
• Schur's inequality
• Schur's theorem
• Schur-convex function
• Schur–Weyl duality
• Lehmer–Schur algorithm
• Schur's property for normed spaces.
• Jordan–Schur theorem
• Schur-Zassenhaus theorem
• Schur triple
• Schur decomposition
• Schur's lower bound

Quotes

In his commemorative speech, Alfred Brauer (PhD candidate Schur) spoke about Issai Schur as follows:^[45] As a teacher, Schur was excellent. His lectures were very clear, but not always easy and required cooperation - During the winter semester of 1930, the number of students who wanted to attend Schur's theory of numbers lecture, was such that the second largest university lecture hall with about 500 seats was too small. His most human characteristics were probably his great modesty, his helpfulness and his human interest in his students.

Heinz Hopf, who had been in Berlin before his appointment to Zurich at the ETH Privatdozent, held - as is clear from oral statements and also from letters - Issai Schur as a mathematician and greatly appreciated man. Here, this appreciation was based entirely on reciprocity: in a letter of 1930 to George Pólya on the occasion of the re-appointment of Hermann Weyl, Schur says of Hopf: Hopf is a very excellent teacher, a mathematician of strong temperament and strong effect, a master's discipline, trained excellent in other areas. - If I have to characterize him as a man, it may suffice if I say that I sincerely look forward to each time I meet with him.

Schur was, however, known for putting a correct distance in personal affairs. The testimony of Hopf is in accordance with statements of Schur's former students in Berlin, by Walter Ledermann and Bernhard Neumann.^[46] One may imagine Issai Schur as a slightly withdrawn, extremely correct and from all sides highly respected professor.

Publications

• Schur, Issai (1968), Grunsky, Helmut, ed., Vorlesungen über Invariantentheorie, Die Grundlehren der mathematischen Wissenschaften, 143, Berlin, New York: Springer-Verlag, MR 0229674
• Schur, Issai (1973), Brauer, Alfred; Rohrbach, Hans, eds., Gesammelte Abhandlungen, Berlin, New York: Springer-Verlag, ISBN 978-3-540-05630-0, MR 0462891

Notes

1. Ledermann, W. (1983). "Issai Schur and his school in Berlin". Bull. London Math. Soc. 15 (2): 97–106. doi:10.1112/blms/15.2.97.
2. Vogt, Annette. Issai Schur: als Wissenschaftler vertrieben. In Schoeps, Grozinger & Mattenklott [401, S. 217–235 (1999)]
3. The Kopelman Foundation. Mogiljow. JewishGen Belarus SIG, on The Jewish Encyclopedia Web site www.jewishgen.org/belarus/je_mogilev.htm conceived, created, and funded by The Kopelman Foundation, accessed 28 December 2003.
4. Blaushild, Immanuel. Libau. In Snyder [423, §1 (c. 1995)]
5. Snyder, Stephen, project coordinator. A Town Named Libau (Liepaja, Latvia). JewishGen Web site www.Jewlshgen.org/ylzkor/libau/libau.html accessed 27 December 2003. (Translation of the 36-page booklet: A Town Named Libau in English, German and Hebrew and additional material about Libau, Editor and Publisher of booklet unknown, believed to have been published in Israel, 1985.)
6. Beare, Arlene, ed. History of Latvia and Courland Web site accessed 1 March 2004: www.jewishgen.org/Latvia/SIG_History_of_Latvia_and_Courland.html (This history is derived from a few sources including [38] but mainly edited from the presentation made by Ruvin Ferber at the 21st International Conference of Jewish Genealogy held in London in July 2001.)
7. vgl. Vogt, Anne
8. Schur, Issai. Über eine Klasse von Matrizen, die sich einer gegebenen Matrix zuordnen lassen. Doctoral dissertation, Universität Berlin, 1901; reprinted in Brauer k Rohrbach [71, Band I, pp. 1–72 (1973)]
9. vgl. Vogt, Anne
10. Chandler, Bruce; Magnus, Wilhelm. The History of Combinatorial Group Theory: A Case Study in the History of Ideas. Studies in the History of Mathematics and Physical Sciences 9. Springer-Verlag, New York, 1982.
11. vgl. Biographie der Leopoldino Carolina
12. Hermann Weyl: Nachlaß. Handschriften und Nachlässe, ETH Bibliothek, 1006:1.
13. Carl Friedrich Geiser (1843-1934), der bei Ludwig Schläfli in Bern promoviert hatte, war von 1873 bis 1913 ordentlicher Professor am Eidgenössischen Polytechnikum in Zürich.
14. 3. Verordnung zur Durchführung des Berufsbeamtengesetzes. Vom 6. Mai 1933, RGBl.I S.245f.
15. Diese sogenannten „Altbeamten“ waren von der Entlassung wegen jüdischer Abstammung vorerst ausgenommen, 1. Verordnung zur Durchführung des Berufsbeamtengesetzes. Vom 11. April 1933, RGBl.I S.195.
16. Walter Ledermann, Peter M. Neumann: The Life of Issai Schur through Letters and other Documents. In Anthony Joseph et al. Studies in Memory of Issai Schur, Birkhäuser 2003. Brief des Ministeriums vom 11. September 1933, Brief von Schur vom 15. September 1933
17. Diese Ansicht vertritt Alfred Brauer in seiner Gedenkrede
18. Schur war sein 1906 mit der Ärztin Regina Frumkin verheiratet. Der Ehe entsprossen zwei Kinder Georg und Hilde. Georg, der etwas älter als Hilde war, studierte Physik und war später als Versicherungsmathematiker in Israel tätig.
19. George Pólya (1887−1985) hatte sich nach seinem Studium in Budapest 1914 und nach Aufenthalten in Göttingen und Paris an der ETH habilitiert. 1928 wurde er zum ordentlichen Professor ernannt. Ab 1940 war er dann in den USA tätig, zuletzt an der Stanford University. - Seine Bekanntschaften mit Schur geht auf die Zeit vor dem Ersten Weltkrieg zurück: Es existieren zahlreiche Briefe von Schur an Pólya aus den Jahren 1913/14, die in den Stanford University Libraries aufbewahrt werden
20. Mitteilung von Frau Susanne Abelin der Enkelin von Issai Schur, Sommer 2001. Der Brief vom 20. August 1935 ist in Walter Ledermann, Peter M. Neumann: The Life of Issai Schur through Letters and other Documents. In Anthony Joseph et al. Studies in Memory of Issai Schur, Birkhäuser 2003. Seite lxxii
21. Die von Hitler und Göring unterschriebene Entpflichtungsurkunde datiert vom 28. September 1935. Siehe Walter Ledermann, Peter M. Neumann: The Life of Issai Schur through Letters and other Documents. In Anthony Joseph et al. Studies in Memory of Issai Schur, Birkhäuser 2003. Seite lxxiv. Die Entlassung wäre anhand des Reichsbürgergesetzes ohnehin spätestens zum 31. Dezember 1935 verfügt worden
22. Der Vorgang ist beschrieben im Buch von Reinhard Siegmund-Schultze: Mathematiker auf der Flucht vor Hitler. Dokumente zur Geschichte der Mathematik, Band 10. Deutsche Mathematiker Vereinigung, Vieweg, 1998. Seite 69/70; die Austrittserklärung datiert vom 6. April 1938. Das Buch enthält darüber hinaus weitere interessante Angaben über die Situation von Schur in den dreißiger Jahren
23. Siehe Volker R. Remmert: Mathematical Publishing in the Third Reich. Math. Intelligencer 22 (3) 2000, Seite 22−30
24. „Long after the war, I talked to Grunsky about that remark and he literally started to cry: You know what I did? I sent him a postcard to contratulate him on his sixtieth birthday. I admired him so much and was very respectful in that card. How lonely he must have been to remember such a small thing”, Schiffer, Menachem Max; Issai Schur. Some Personal Reminiscences (1986); 1998 in: Begehr, H. (Hrsg.), Mathematik in Berlin. Geschichte und Dokumentation, 1998 Aachen.
25. Siehe dazu und für das Folgende: Alfred Brauers Gedenkrede
26. Vergleiche den Brief des Reichsministers für Wissenschaft, Erziehung und Volksbildung an Issai Schur vom 24. Februar 1939. Walter Ledermann, Peter M. Neumann: The Life of Issai Schur through Letters and other Documents. In Anthony Joseph et al. Studies in Memory of Issai Schur, Birkhäuser 2003. Seite lxxxi
27. veröffentlicht von Alfred Brauer und Hans Rohrbach
28. See Festschrift der DMV Seite 549
29. Polynomial representations of $GL(n)$ ISBN 978-0-387-10258-0
30. vgö. Chandler, Bruce; Magnus, Wilhelm.
31. Briining, Jochen; Ferus, Dirk; Siegmund-Schultze; Reinhard. Terror and Exile: Persecution and Expulsion of Mathematicians from Berlin between 1933 and 1945. An Exhibition on the Occasion of the International Congress of Mathematicians, Technische Universitat Berlin, August 19 to 27, 1998, Deutsche Mathematiker-Vereinigung, Berlin, 1998.
32. Pinl, Max; Furtmiiller, Lux. Mathematicians under Hitler. Seite 178
33. vgl. Briining, Jochen Seite 27
34. Pinl, Max; Furtmiiller, Lux. Mathematicians under Hitler. Seite 178
35. Soifer, Alexander. Issai Schur: Ramsey theory before Ramsey. Geombinatorics, 5 (1995), 6–23
36. Urs Stammbach Die Zürcher Vorlesung von Issai Schur über Darstellungstheorie Seite xiii, ETH-Bibliothek 2004
37. Schulratsarchiv der ETH-Zürich. Akten 1935/36, ETH-Bibliothek.
38. Protokoller der Abteilung IX, Mathematik und Physik. Protokolle der Konferenzen der Abt. IX, Hs 1079:3, Handschriften und Nachlässe, ETH-Bibliothek Zürich
39. Schulratsarchiv der ETH-Zürich. Missiven 1935, 3119, ETH-Bibliothek
40. Schulratsarchiv der ETH-Zürich. Akten 1935/36, ETH-Bibliothek
41. Gemäß einem später geschriebenen Lebenslauf - siehe Walter Ledermann, Peter M. Neumann: The Life of Issai Schur through Letters and other Documents. In Anthony Joseph et al. Studies in Memory of Issai Schur. Seite lxxvii, Birkhäuser 2003. - fanden die Vorlesungen zwischen dem 4. und dem 18. Februar statt
42. Siehe Department of Special Collections and University Archives, Stanford University Libraries, 26. Februar 1936.
43. Der Vorgang wird beschrieben in Charles Curtis: Pioneers of representation theory. History of Mathematics vol. 15, Amer. Math. Soc./London Math. Soc. 1999, Seite 131
44. Siehe Mathematics Genealogy Project, North Dakota State University
45. Gedenkrede vom 8. November 1960 anlässlich der Schur-Gedenkfeier im Rahmen der 150-Jahrfeier der Universität Berlin. Siehe Issai Schur: Gesammelte Abhandlungen, Seiten v-xiv. Alfred Brauer hat 1928 bei Schur promoviert.
46. Siehe Interview with Bernhard Neumann, Newsletter of the European Mathematical Society, 39, March 2001, 9-11; Walter Ledermann: Issai Schur and his school in Berlin, Bull. London Math. Soc. 15 (1983), 97-106. Bernhard Neumann doktorierte 1932, Walter Ledermann bestand das Examen für Lehramtskandidaten im Jahre 1933

References

• Curtis, Charles W. (2003), Pioneers of Representation Theory: Frobenius, Burnside, Schur, and Brauer, History of Mathematics, Providence, R.I.: American Mathematical Society, ISBN 978-0-8218-2677-5, MR 1715145Review
• Joseph, Anthony; Melnikov, Anna; Rentschler, Rudolf, eds. (2003), Studies in memory of Issai Schur, Progress in Mathematics, 210, Boston, MA: Birkhäuser Boston, ISBN 978-0-8176-4208-2, MR 1985184

External links

• O'Connor, John J.; Robertson, Edmund F., "Issai Schur", MacTutor History of Mathematics archive, University of St Andrews.
• Issai Schur at the Mathematics Genealogy Project