Thomas Lavy

Not to be confused with Thomas Levy.
Thomas Lavy

Lavy, from a 1995 newspaper article.
Born Thomas Lewis Lavy
(1941-12-18)December 18, 1941
Winfield, Missouri
Died December 23, 1995(1995-12-23) (aged 54)
Little Rock, Arkansas
Nationality American
Occupation Farmer

Thomas Lewis Lavy (December 18, 1941–December 23, 1995) was an American farmer who attempted to cross the Canada–US border into Canada from Alaska with several firearms, ricin poison and $89,000 in cash in 1993. He was turned away at the border, and the poison impounded. His intentions were never clear, as he hanged himself in his jail cell four days after being arrested by the FBI on terrorism charges more than two years after the incident was first reported.

Some media outlets called the incident a "thwarted terrorist attack" resulting in the death of the perpetrator,[1] while others have suggested Lavy was the innocent victim of a "tragic case" of an overzealous FBI agent and prosecutor.[2][3] One journalist opined this may well be "another case where the government hounds some poor guy without mercy...until he kills himself".[4]

Life

The pipeline terminal in Valdez

The second child of Lilleton Lavy and Cora Yates,[5] Lavy served as a military policeman during the Korean War.[6] Considered a naturalist who enjoyed gardening and hunting, he also kept a collection of exotic books, including several on elephant hunting.[6][7] He was married to Rebecca Davis, with whom he lived in Virginia, and had two children, Lewis Edward Lavy and Lisa Kay Hoelting (née Lavy).[5]

The Associated Press dubbed Lavy a survivalist;[2] his family denied he had any such leanings.[8] CQ Press claimed that Lavy was an alleged white supremacist,[9] based on unsubstantiated reports that "Neo-Nazi" literature may have been found in his vehicle.[10] In the 1970s, Lavy worked as a radio repairman for Motorola in Oklahoma City.[6] He also lived in Troy, Missouri[6] before taking a job as an electrician for an oil company on the Alyeska Pipeline in Valdez, Alaska.[6][10] In the autumn of 1992, he visited his sister Betty Krieg and her husband Bill in Harvester, Missouri, and told them that he hoped to retire and purchase a small property where he could raise chickens and tend a garden.[11] Several months later, he announced that he had found the perfect place, a cottage on six acres of land in Onia, Arkansas. Lavy packed his belongings for the move south in April 1993.[6]

Crossing the border

US Customs office at Alcan/Beaver Creek border crossing
“ [Lavy] had perpetrated no clear threat; the mere possession of the ricin was not itself a violation of federal law. ”
— Robert M. Burnham, Chief of the Domestic Terrorism Section at the FBI[12]

He crossed from Alaska into Canada in his truck at the Beaver Creek, Yukon border crossing.[13] on 8 April 1993.[14][15] Lavy was "honest and forthright" when he explained to Customs officials that he had a shotgun, two .22 calibre rifles and a muzzleloading rifle,[14] 20,000 rounds of ammunition, $89,000 and 130 grams (approximately 0.28 of a pound) of ricin, considered third amongst the world's most deadly substances.[16][17] In his car were two books, one describing how to extract ricin from castor beans, and another discussing ways to poison with toxic compounds;[18] likely the books Silent Death and another some media reports dubbed The Poisoner's Handbook[10] and others dubbed The Prisoner's Handbook.[19] There were also reports mentioning a third book, titled Get Even: The Complete Book of Dirty Tricks.[13]

Lavy explained his possession of the ricin, which he claimed to have taken from the U.S. Army,[19][20][21] was for use on his farms against coyotes. He also told them that he kept it beside his cash as a deterrence against theft since a criminal would likely believe it was cocaine and kill himself snorting it.[10][22] Another report said that he suggested he may coat his money in the powder, to prevent anyone stealing it.[23] Federal officials did not believe his story about killing coyotes, equating it to using a thermonuclear device to ward off burglars.[17]

After calling the U.S. Customs to run a criminal background check which came back negative,[13] Lavy was denied entry into Canada, fined $750 for trying to import the weapons,[14] and the ricin powder was confiscated. He was then released back into the United States and told to report to U.S. Customs; he did so, he declared $22,500 in cash and listed his address in Valdez as PO Box 1297.[14] At this point, it seemed clear that no laws were considered to have been broken, and no prosecution would be forthcoming.[10]

Canadian officials alerted their American counterparts of the incident, and also informed the Alaskan military base from which Lavy claimed to have stolen the poison. Neither were interested; they stated that they were unaware of any theft or crime being committed.[10] It took the Canadians nearly a month before they understood the danger posed by ricin and transferred the bag to a container for hazardous materials. It was kept in storage for nearly two years.[10] In this case, neither the Canadian nor American authorities had "heard of" ricin, and thus did not realise what it was.[24] Lavy entered the Lower 48 through Portal, North Dakota on April 12, this time he listed his mailing address in Arkansas, PO Box 894, HC 73, Onia.[14]

Arrest and death

By this time, Attorney General Janet Reno was actively monitoring the case, and the FBI headquarters was getting "hyped" about the upcoming raid.[14]
“ I knew immediately that we had badly overreacted to the situation. However, a simple low-key arrest would not have accomplished headquarter's goal of having a terrorist incident to hype on the network news. ”
— FBI Agent Ivian C. Smith[14]

In the Spring of 1995, FBI agent Thomas Lynch, previously involved in the ricin investigation of the Minnesota Patriots Council militia, was transferred to the FBI's Anchorage bureau in Alaska. Once there he learned of the Lavy-border-crossing-incident two years earlier and requested a Grand Jury convene to charge Lavy. On December 12, a Grand Jury recommended prosecution of Lavy.[10]

After the fact, some journalists questioned why or how the FBI got involved at all.[4] Lynch forwarded case details to the Little Rock FBI office, where it was assigned to agent Roy Christopher in Jonesboro. He determined that Lavy was an active member of the American Legion and had no arrest record, not even a driving violation.[14] Christopher enlisted the help of agent Ivian C. Smith in drawing up a raid plan for the cottage where Lavy lived alone. The agents received day and nighttime aerial photographs from the FBI's Nightstalker aircraft.[14] One FBI official later commented that "FBI headquarters was going to turn the Lavy arrest and search into a media event."[14]

During the same period, the Canadian Customs station had been cleaned and the powder in storage was rediscovered and sent to a military doctor for examination. He confirmed it was ricin, only 7% pure,[25] and it was sent to Fort Detrick in the United States to assist in the prosecution of Lavy.[10]

In violation of the Posse Comitatus Act prohibiting the use of the military in domestic policing, members of the U.S. Army and Navy based in Aberdeen, Maryland[26] joined with a 50-man team consisting of FBI agents, six members of the Hostage Rescue Team and the local sheriff Fred Black in storming the stone cottage Lavy owned in Onia, Arkansas on December 20. The team sneaked up on the residence through a neighboring cemetery.[14][16][27] The fifty men encircled Lavy's house dressed in military and camoflouge fatigues and when Lavy noticed one staking out his house, he took his shotgun outside and approached agent Mark Jessie on the edge of his yard. Upon being informed that they were police officers, despite their lack of identification, Lavy placed his gun on the ground and allowed them to handcuff him.[14] One FBI officer present later remarked that it was clear Lavy had no idea why he was the subject of a raid, and that his failed border crossing two years earlier likely never occurred to him.[14]

Lavy was arrested without a struggle and was "completely truthful" and "completely cooperative" in explaining the contents of his house to the officials.[14] Since the search of his house turned up only legal weapons, and even his simple possession of Ricin two years earlier was completely legal, he was charged with "possession of a toxin with intent to use it as a weapon" under the Biological Weapons Anti-Terrorism Act of 1989.[15][17] Despite the charge, police found no ricin at the time of the arrest,[10] although they did find several castor beans in a tin designed for Christmas fruitcake,[2] which he had purchased by mail from a woman in Oregon.[19] Other contents seized at the house included several collector-model rifles, five pistols, several thousand dollars in cash and Krugerrand gold.[19]

“ Can you imagine being 54 years old and never arrested in your life, and being incarcerated and told you're facing potential life imprisonment on a situation that [you] were totally innocent of? ”
— Attorney Sam Hauer[28]

Lavy appointed Sam Hauer as his attorney.[27] At the bail hearing on December 23, FBI agent Lynch testified that Lavy's powder was potent enough to kill 32,000 people, and that the charge could merit life imprisonment.[26] U.S. Magistrate Jerry W. Cavaneau said that the government had not produced any evidence suggesting criminal intent, but ordered Lavy held without bail at the Pulaski County Detention Facility in Little Rock until a January court date in Alaska.[7][18]

That night Lavy tied his shirt around his neck and around the prison bars, then sat down until he slowly strangled to death.[14] The prisoner suicide was discovered at 6 a.m. by a guard. Lavy was taken to University Hospital and declared legally dead at 7am.[16]

Aftermath

Following Lavy's death, the ricin was shipped back to Canada for destruction.[10] Lavy's funeral was held at Kemper-Marsh Funeral Home,[29] and he was buried at the Asbury Cemetery, in Foley, Missouri.[6]

In 2003, Richard Sand wrote a fiction book in which the protagonist Lucas Rook was responsible for arranging the "suicide" of Lavy, who was portrayed as a poisoner.[30] In March 1996, three months after the raid that led to Lavy's suicide, the United States Senate characterized the FBI's belief about the incident, noting that Lavy may have been trying to "fund and arm an underground terrorist militia".[31] However, the report also confused the contents of Lavy's vehicle in 1993 and contents of his house following the 1995 raid.[31] Ultimately, Hauer blamed Lavy's death on the actions of Robert Bundry, the "over-zealous" Alaskan prosecutor, and an unnamed FBI agent similarly enthused at the idea of taking Lavy down.[32]

Footnotes

  1. ↑ "Terrorist attacks and related incidents in the United States". Johnstonsarchive.net. Retrieved 2012-02-27.
  2. 1 2 3 Deadly Poison, Fatal Mystery Toxic terror or overkill? Probers seek answers,; suicide blocks way By Michael Dorman
  3. ↑ SUICIDE LEAVES QUESTIONS IN POISON CASE SOURCE: William C. Lhotka Of the Post-Dispatch Staff, Some information for this story was provided by the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette. PUBLICATION: St. Louis Post-Dispatch (MO) DATE: December 31, 1995
  4. 1 2 Poke McHenry, Waycross Journal-Herald, April 4, 1996, Newspapers Don't Always Tell the "Hole" Story"
  5. 1 2 "Family Tree Maker's Genealogy Site: Genealogy Report: Descendants of John Dixon". Familytreemaker.genealogy.com. Retrieved 2012-02-27.
  6. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 St Louis Post Dispatch, Jan 02, 1996, obituaries
  7. 1 2 "Man Arrested In Poison Case Kills Himself In Jail Cell - New York Times". Nytimes.com. 1995-12-24. Retrieved 2012-02-27.
  8. ↑ Jailed man who hanged self defended Author: Associated Press Publish Date: December 30, 1995
  9. ↑ "Current Events In Context : Terrorism". CQ Press. Retrieved 2012-02-27.
  10. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Bioterrorism and biocrimes: the illicit use of biological agents , 2002
  11. ↑ ARREST AND SUICIDE STUNS FAMILY: SISTER HERE CAN'T BELIEVE BROTHER HAD TERRORIST IDEAS. Article from: St Louis Post-Dispatch (MO) | January 7, 1996 | Lhotka, William C. |
  12. ↑ Statement for the Record of Robert M. Burnham, Chief, Domestic Terrorism Section, Federal Bureau of Investigation, before the United States House of Representatives Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations, May 20, 1999.
  13. 1 2 3 Michael Reynolds, The Playboy Book of True Crime, reprint from Playboy, November 1996
  14. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Ivian C. Smith (2004). Inside: A Top G-Man Exposes Spies, Lies and Bureaucratic Bungling. Thomas Nelson Publishers. pp. 175–180. ISBN 978-1-59555-333-1.
  15. 1 2 Terrorist suspect hangs himself [Final Edition] The Record - Kitchener, Ont. Date: Dec 26, 1995 Start Page: B.8 Section: Local
  16. 1 2 3 Farmer, suspected of making poison, a suicide. St. Petersburg Times - St. Petersburg, Fla.Date: Dec 24, 1995 Start Page: 3.A Section: NATIONAL Text Word Count: 516
  17. 1 2 3 The Vindicator - Dec 23, 1995. Man who carried deadly beans faces charges
  18. 1 2 CNS WMD Terrorism Research Project (February 29, 2008). "Chronology of Incidents Involving Ricin". James Martin Center for Nonproliferation Studies (CNS). Monterey Institute of International Studies.
  19. 1 2 3 4 John Kifner (December 23, 1995), "Antiterrorism Law Used In -Poison Smuggling Case; Man Had Enough Powder for Mass Killing", New York Times
  20. ↑ Smuggler's lethal secret buried with him, Vancouver Sun, January 20, 1996
  21. ↑ Jailed Man Who Hanged Self Defended, Dallas Morning News, December 30, 1995
  22. ↑ Michael Dorman, "Deadly Poison, Fatal Mystery", Newsday, January 7, 1996. P. A10
  23. ↑ "Ricin". snopes.com. Retrieved 2012-02-27.
  24. ↑ SEIZED POISON SET OFF FEW ALARMS OFFICIALS AT BORDER SLOW TO RECOGNIZE ALASKAN'S DEADLY POWDER Author: PETER S. GOODMAN Daily News reporter Staff Date: January 4, 1996 Publication: Anchorage Daily News (AK)
  25. ↑ William C. Lhotka, “Suicide leaves questions in poison case,” St. Louis Post-Dispatch, December 31, 1995, p. E1.
  26. 1 2 Deadly Poison, Fatal Mystery Toxic terror or overkill? Probers seek answers,; suicide blocks way By Michael Dorman
  27. 1 2 San Jose Mercury News (CA) - December 24, 1995 - 4A Front MAN ARRESTED FOR POSSESSING DEADLY POISON HANGS HIMSELF
  28. ↑ Star-News, Dec. 24, 1995
  29. ↑ OBITUARIES.(St. Charles), Article from: St Louis Post-Dispatch (MO) | January 2, 1996
  30. ↑ Hands of Vengeance, Richard Sand, 2003
  31. 1 2 Global proliferation of weapons of mass destruction : hearings before the Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations of the Committee on Governmental Affairs, United States Senate, One Hundred Fourth Congress, first session
  32. ↑ Man- Arrested In Poison Case Kills Himself In Jail Cell By JOHN KIFNER New York Times 24xii95
This article is issued from Wikipedia - version of the 10/10/2016. The text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution/Share Alike but additional terms may apply for the media files.