Cochise County in the Old West

Cochise County in the Old West

Cochise County in 1881, at the beginning of the silver boom.
Date	c.1850 – 1900
Location	Cochise County, Arizona

Cochise County in the Old West was the site of ongoing Apache Indian attacks and a bitter feud between outlaw Cowboys and lawmen like Virgil Earp and his brothers. The county was carved off in 1881 from the easternmost portion of Pima County during a formative period in the American Southwest. Tensions began as soon as American settlers began arriving in what is now Cochise County. The time period was characterized by rapidly growing boomtowns, ongoing Apache raids, smuggling and cattle rustling across the United States-Mexico border, growing ranching operations, and the expansion of new technologies in mining, railroading, and telecommunications.

In the 1860s, following the Gadsden Purchase and the arrival of American settlers, conflict between the Apaches and the Americans was at its height. Pima County and later Cochise County were located in the center of the Apache wars and until 1886 there was almost constant warfare in that region adjacent to the Mexican border.

In addition to the conflict with the Native Americans, during the 1870s and 1880s, there was considerable tension between the rural residents who were for the most part Democrats from the agrarian Confederate States and town residents and business owners who were largely Republicans from the industrial Union States. The tension culminated in what has been called the Cochise County feud, or the Earp-Clanton feud, which ended with the historic Gunfight at the O.K. Corral and Wyatt Earp's Vendetta Ride. Dr. George E. Goodfellow described Tombstone, the capital of Cochise County, as the "condensation of wickedness."^[1]

Origins and formation

Apache Wars

A pile of stones in Skeleton Canyon, marking the site of Geronimo's surrender in 1886.

In the southern portion of the Gadsen Purchase, later known as Pima County and then including Cochise County, there was considerable, ongoing conflict between Americans and Chiricahua Apaches. The area itself was located in the middle of the Chiricahua's homeland and they resisted the Americans' encroachment on their land for decades. The Chiricahua War began with the Bascom Affair. In January 1861, a band of Apaches raided the ranch of John Ward, stole some livestock, and kidnapped the son of a Mexican woman who lived with Ward.

Cochise and the Bascom Affair

Ward wrongly believed that Cochise and his followers were responsible and he demanded that the United States Army confront the Apache leader, recover his livestock, and rescue the boy. A month later, the army responded by sending Lieutenant George Bascom and fifty-four men into Apache Pass, where several people had been massacred by the Chiricahuas in the past. After setting up camp about a mile from the Butterfield Overland Mail station, Bascom lured Cochise into his tent and threatened to hold him hostage until Ward's property and the boy were returned. Furious and insulted, Cochise cut through the wall of the tent and eluded the guards posted outside. Fighting broke out and continued until 1886 when the Apache shaman Geronimo surrendered at Skeleton Canyon. But even after Geronimo's surrender, warriors like Massai and the Apache Kid continued to raid settler's ranches until after the turn of the century.^[2][3][4]

Formation

Cochise County was created on February 1, 1881 from the eastern portion of Pima County.^[5] It was named after the legendary Chiricahua Apache war chief Cochise.^[6] The county seat was Tombstone until 1929 when it moved to Bisbee. Cochise County is almost a perfect square: 83 by 84 miles (134 by 135 km). It contains 6,972 square miles (18,060 km²), or one and one-half times the size of the state of Connecticut. Dragoon Summit divides the county. The county includes 2,000 square miles (5,200 km²) of the San Pedro River watershed.^[7]

Battle of Apache Pass

Between 1861 and 1886, there were dozens of skirmishes against the Apaches in Cochise County, however, the biggest of these battles all occurred when Cochise and Mangas Coloradas attempted to ambush a detachment of the California Column as it made its way east through Apache Pass. During the ensuing Battle of Apache Pass, on June 15, 1862, Captain Thomas L. Roberts and 126 men routed 500 Apaches from their fortified positions overlooking the area. Sixty-six Apaches were killed while the Americans suffered only five casualties. The army then built Fort Bowie to protect the trail that led through the pass.^[8]

Cochise County conflicts

Rural vs. town interests

Many of the ranchers and Cowboys who lived in the Cochise County countryside were resentful of the growing power of the business owners and townspeople who increasingly influenced local politics and law in the county. A cowboy in that time and region was generally regarded as an outlaw. Legitimate cowmen were referred to as cattle herders or ranchers.^[9]:194

The ranchers largely maintained control of the country around Tombstone, due in large part to the sympathetic support of Cochise County Sheriff Johnny Behan who favored the Cowboys and rural ranchers^[10] and who grew to intensely dislike the Earps. Behan tended to ignore the Earp's complaints about the McLaury's and Clanton's horse thieving and cattle rustling.

The townspeople and business owners welcomed the Cowboys who had money to spend in the numerous bordellos, gambling halls, and drinking establishments. When lawlessness got out of hand, they enacted ordinances to control the disruptive revelry and shootings. As officers of the law, the Earp brothers held authority at times on the federal, county and local level. They were resented by the Cowboys for their tactics as when Wyatt Earp buffaloed Curly Bill when he accidentally shot Marshal Fred White.^[11]:221 The Earps were also known to bend the law in their favor when it affected their gambling and saloon interests, which earned them further enmity with the Cowboy faction.^[12]

Under the surface were other tensions aggravating the simmering distrust. Most of the leading cattlemen and Cowboys were Confederate sympathizers and Democrats from Southern states, especially Missouri and Texas.^[13] The mine and business owners, miners, townspeople and city lawmen including the Earps were largely Republicans from the Northern states. There was also the fundamental conflict over resources and land, of traditional, Southern-style, “small government” agrarianism of the rural Cowboys contrasted to Northern-style industrial capitalism.^[14]

Outlaw Cowboys

During the rapid growth of Cochise County in the 1880s at the peak of the silver mining boom, outlaws derisively called "Cowboys", frequently robbed stagecoaches and brazenly stole cattle in broad daylight, scaring off the legitimate cowboys watching the herds.^[15] It became an insult to call a legitimate cattleman a "Cowboy." Legal cowmen were generally called herders or ranchers.^[16]

Cowboys as lawmen

The lines between the outlaw element and law enforcement were not always distinct. Doc Holliday had a reputation as a killer, though modern research has only identified three individuals he shot. He was also friends with Bill Leonard, who was implicated in a stagecoach robbery. Cowboy Frank Stilwell was a known cattle rustler and served as an assistant Sheriff under Cochise County Sheriff Johnny Behan. Cowboy and outlaw Texas Jack Vermillion was a friend of the Earps who deputized him after Virgil Earp was maimed in an ambush.

Murder of Deputies Adams and Finley

At the behest of Judge Charles Silent, Territorial Marshal Crawley Dake deputized John H. Adams and Cornelius Finley.^[17]:113 While traveling north to company headquarters in September 1878, less than two weeks after they were deputized, five Mexicans intercepted Adams and Finley, who they believed were carrying gold ore, and killed them, but didn't find any ore. One of the suspects in their killing was Florentino Saiz, who the Arizona Weekly Star identified as "the 1878 murderer of Deputy U.S. Marshals Cornelius Finley and John Hicks Adams on September 2, 1878". During the Coroner's Inquest into the death of Morgan Earp, Pete Spence's wife, Marietta Duarte, implicated her husband and four other men, including Florentino Cruz, in Morgan's murder.^{[18]:248[19]:176} Saiz and Cruz may have been the same person.^[20][21] In 1879, the Mexican federal government refused to allow Dake to extradite two of the suspects.^[17]:114 Unable to find justice in the courts for his brother's murder, Wyatt Earp began a vendetta, and killed Florentino Cruz on March 22, 1882 at a wood camp near South Pass of the Dragoon Mountains.^[22]

Smuggling and cattle rustling

From early in the history of Pima County, bandits used the border between the United States and Mexico to raid across in one direction and use the other as sanctuary. In December, 1878, and again the next year, Mexican authorities complained about American outlaw Cowboys who stole Mexican beef and resold it in Arizona. The Arizona Citizen reported that both U.S. and Mexican bandits were stealing horses from the Santa Cruz Valley and selling the livestock in Sonora, Mexico. Arizona Territorial Governor Fremont investigated the Mexican government's allegations and accused them in turn of allowing outlaws to use Sonora as a base of operations for raiding into Arizona.^[23]

The Clanton and McLaury clans were among those allegedly involved in the clandestine cross-border livestock smuggling from Sonora into Arizona. The illegal cattle operations kept beef prices lower and provided cheap stock that helped small ranchers get by. Many early Tombstone residents looked the other way when it was "only Mexicans" being robbed.^[16]

The Clanton family led by Newman Haynes Clanton had a ranch about 15 miles (24 km) southeast of Tombstone that was a way station for stolen Mexican beef. He was assisted by his sons Ike, Billy, and Phin Clanton. Frank and Tom McLaury had a ranch outside of Tombstone that they used to buy and re-sell stolen Mexican cattle.

On July 25, 1880, Captain Joseph H. Hurst requested the assistance of Deputy U.S. Marshal Virgil Earp, who brought Wyatt and Morgan Earp, as well as Wells Fargo agent Marshall Williams, to track the thieves of six U.S. Army mules stolen from Camp Rucker. This was a federal matter because the animals were U.S. property. They found the animals on the McLaury's Ranch on the Babacomari River and the branding iron used to change the "US" brand to "D8".^[9]

To avoid bloodshed, Cowboy Frank Patterson promised to return the mules so the posse withdrew. The Cowboys showed up two days later without the mules and laughed at Captain Hurst and the Earps. Hurst responded by printing and distributing a handbill describing the theft and promising a reward for the "trial and conviction" of the thieves. He specifically charged Frank McLaury with assisting with the theft. It was reprinted in the Epitaph on July 30, 1880.^[9] Frank McLaury angrily printed a response in the Cowboy-friendly Nuggett, calling Hurst "a coward, a vagabond, a rascal, and a malicious liar."

In late 1879 one of Wyatt Earp's prized horses named Dick Naylor was stolen.^[24]:129 Almost a year later he got a tip that it had been seen at the Clanton ranch near Charleston. Earp rode out to their ranch and spotted the horse. Ike Clanton and his brother Billy were both present. Earp returned with Holliday to recover the horse. On the way, they overtook Behan, who was riding in a wagon. Behan was also heading to the ranch to serve an election-hearing subpoena on Ike Clanton.^[25]

Pleasant Valley War

At the start of the Pleasant Valley War, a notorious feud that took place in Arizona's Tonto Basin from 1882-1892, the smuggler Neil McLeod left Globe, Arizona for Cochise County. Many Cochise County cattle dealers were losing cattle and horses to thieves that T. W. Ayles described as an "organized band" whose "connections seem to extend to and over the Mexican border."^[26]

In the middle of 1881, the Mexican military dropped taxes on alcohol and tobacco and began vigorously pursuing the Cowboys. In response, the rustlers increased their stock thefts on the U.S. side of the border. McLeod used boxing matches and wrestling as a cover for his less scrupulous activities of rustling and selling contraband near the Mexican border.^[27][28]

Prizefighting had become quite sophisticated in Tombstone and in October 1883 McLeod beat the then champion Young in four rounds and was awarded a $400 prize.^[28] McLeod also maintained good relations with Judge Aaron H. Hackney in Globe by helping the Judge's friends caught in the feud, including Frederick Russell Burnham, leave the Tonto Basin to hide out in Tombstone.^[27] In August 1884, McLeod was assassinated in Nacosair, Sonora, Mexico by James Powers.^[29]

First Skeleton Canyon Massacre

Skeleton Canyon is located in the Peloncillo Mountains, which straddles the modern Arizona and New Mexico state border. This canyon connects the Animas Valley of New Mexico with the San Simon Valley of Arizona. The first Skeleton Canyon massacres was an attack on Mexican Rurales by rustlers in July 1879. They attacked a rancho in northern Sonora, killing several of the inhabitants. After the attack on the rancho, the survivors reported the attacks to Commandant Francisco Neri and he sent a detachment of Rurales out, among them Captain Alfredo Carrillo. The Rurales illegally crossed the border into Arizona and as the Rurales entered in the canyon, shots were fired. Three of the Rurales survived the initial onslaught. Then the Cowboys executed the Rurales leader.

The Mexican Government protested the killings to President Chester Arthur despite the fact that the Mexican policemen had crossed into a foreign country where they had no jurisdiction. Although the assailants were never positively identified, it was speculated that Old Man Clanton, Ike Clanton, Billy Clanton, "Curly Bill" Brocius, Johnny Ringo, and Florentino Cruz were the murderers.

Governor Fremont asks for militia

Territorial Governor John C. Frémont, who had been the first Republican presidential candidate in 1856, was largely an absentee appointee. But in February 1881 he suggested to the territorial Legislature that they fund a state militia to ride against the outlaws and stop the rustling. The legislators hooted down his plan.^[30]

Second Skeleton Canyon Massacre

In July 1881, "Curly Bill" Brocius received word that several Mexican smugglers carrying silver were heading to the United States through Skeleton Canyon. Johnny Ringo reported that Curly Bill and several other men including Old Man Clanton, Ike Clanton, Billy Clanton, Frank McLaury, Tom McLaury, Billy Grounds, and Zwing Hunt hid in the rocks high above the trail. As the smugglers rode through the canyon the murderers opened fire, killing six of the nineteen. The rest were killed as they tried to get away.

Guadalupe Canyon Massacre

In August 1881, Mexican Commandant Felipe Neri dispatched troops to the border.^[31]:110 Some researchers theorize that Mexican Rurales led by Captain Alfredo Carrillo, who had survived the Skeleton Canyon Massacre in 1879,^[32] led the ambush of the Cowboys. They found "Old Man" Clanton and six others bedded down for the night in Guadalupe Canyon with a herd of cattle. The Mexicans waited until dawn and killed five of the Cowboys.

The dead included Old Man Clanton; Charley Snow, a ranch hand who thought he had heard a bear and was the first killed; Jim Crain, who was wanted for the stagecoach robbery near Tombstone during which Bud Philpott had been murdered; Dick Gray, son of Col. Mike Gray; and Billy Lang, a cattle rancher. Clanton, Crain, and Gray were either still in their bedrolls or in the act of getting dressed when killed. Lang was the only one who had a chance to fight back. Harry Ernshaw, a milk farmer, was grazed by a bullet on the nose; Billy Byers feigned death until the soldiers left.^{[31]:97–98[33][34]}

Tombstone marshal killed

On October 28, 1880, Tombstone town marshal Fred White was trying to break up a group of late revelers shooting at the moon on Allen Street in Tombstone. He attempted to confiscate the pistol of Curly Bill Brocius and was shot in the abdomen. Wyatt Earp buffaloed Brocius, knocking him unconscious, and arrested him. Wyatt told his biographer many years later that he thought Brocious was still armed at the time and didn't notice that Brocius' pistol was already on the ground.^[35] The pistol contain only one expended cartridge and five live rounds. Brocius waived a preliminary hearing so he and his case could be transferred to Tucson District Court. White died two days after his shooting changing Brocious' charge to murder.

On December 27, 1880, Wyatt testified that he thought the shooting was accidental. It was also demonstrated that Brocius' pistol could be fired from half-cock. Fred White also left a statement before he died that the shooting was not intentional. The judge released Brocius, but Brocius retained bitterness towards Earp for the rough treatment he got when arrested.^[36]

Gunfight at the O.K. Corral

Tombstone, Arizona in 1891.

On October 26, 1881, town marshal and Deputy U. S. Marshall Virgil Earp led his brothers and deputies Wyatt and James along with Doc Holliday in a confrontation with five outlaw Cowboys: Wesley Fuller, Tom and Frank McLaury, Billy Claiborne and Ike Clanton. The Cowboys were armed in violation of a city city ordinance prohibiting carrying weapons in town.^[37] This shootout became famous as the Gunfight at the O.K. Corral.

Wes Fuller, Ike Clanton, and Billy Claiborne ran from the fight unharmed, but Billy Clanton and both McLaury brothers were killed. It took place at about 3:00 pm on October 26, 1881, in Tombstone, Arizona Territory of the United States. Although only three men were killed during the gunfight, it is generally regarded as the most famous gunfight in the history of the Old West.

Despite its name, the gunfight began in a 15–20 feet (4.6–6.1 m) wide empty lot or alley on Fremont Street, between C. S. Fly's lodging house and photographic studio and the MacDonald assay house. The lot was six doors east of an alleyway that served as the O.K. Corral's rear entrance. The two opposing parties were initially only about 6 feet (1.8 m) apart. About thirty shots were fired in thirty seconds. Ike Clanton and Billy Claiborne ran from the fight, unharmed. Frank and Tom McLaury and Billy Clanton were killed; Morgan Earp, Virgil Earp, and Doc Holliday were wounded and survived. Ike Clanton filed murder charges against Doc Holliday and the Earps and after a month-long preliminary hearing they were exonerated.

The Earps and Doc Holliday were charged by Billy Clanton's brother, Ike Clanton, with murder but were eventually exonerated by a local judge after a 30-day preliminary hearing and then again by a local grand jury. The so-called cowboy faction allegedly targeted the Earps for assassination over the next six months, which led to a series of killings and retributions, often with federal and county lawmen supporting different sides of the conflict. The series of battles became known as the Earp Vendetta Ride. The Earps and Doc Holliday left Arizona and the Cowboy element was less of a threat from that point forward.

Shootings commonplace

On April 6, 1880, only two months after he arrived, Tombstone resident George Parsons wrote in his diary, "Several more shooting scrapes but they are of such frequent occurrence that their novelty has ceased."^[38]

Death of jealous husband

In mid-June 1880, Buckskin Frank Leslie who had an eye for the ladies, escorted Mary Killen, the Commercial Hotel's housekeeper, to a dance.^[39] Accounts differ as to whether she was separated from her husband^[40] or still married to him.^[39] After the dance, they sat on the porch of the Cosmopolitan Hotel and were spotted by her drunken husband.^[41] Killen appeared out of the dark street and shot at Leslie, barely missing him. Leslie fired back and shot Mike Killen twice. Mike Killen died five days later and was buried in Tombstone's Boot Hill cemetery on June 22, 1880.^[42] Buckskin Frank Leslie had fired in self-defense and wasn't arrested.

Murder of Henry Schneider

On January 14, 1881, gambler Michael O'Rourke (aka Johnny Behind the Deuce) got into a disagreement with Henry Schneider chief engineer of the Tombstone Mining and Milling Company, at a restaurant during lunch. According to the Epitaph, Schneider suspected O'Rourke had stolen several articles of clothing from Schneider's cabin, but could not prove it. The next day Schneider went to lunch and he and O'Rourke got into a disagreement. According to O'Rourke and two friends of his, Schneider produced a knife and O'Rourke shot him in self-defense.^[43][44] Another stated that O'Rourke took offense at something Schneider said and threatened him, saying, "Goddamn you, I'll shoot you when you come out." He waited for Schneider outside and killed him—O'Rourke said in self-defense. Charleston's constable George McKelvey arrested O'Rourke. Henry was well-liked and a mob of miners quickly gathered, threatening to lynch O'Rourke on the spot. McKelvey took O'Rourke on a buckboard wagon to Tombstone and the mob followed. Once in Tombstone, Tombstone Marshal Ben Sippy, with the assistance of Deputy U.S. Marshal Virgil Earp, Assistant City Marshal Morgan Earp, and former Pima County Sheriff Wyatt Earp held the crowd at bay until calm prevailed.^[45]:39

Luke Short kills Charlie Storms

In February 1881, Luke Short and professional gambler and gunfighter Charlie Storms had a verbal altercation about a faro game which was defused by Bat Masterson, who knew both men. On February 28, Storm confronted Short once again outside the Oriental Saloon. This time he pulled a .45 caliber revolver. But Storm was too slow and Short shot him in the chest at point-blank range, his muzzle flash setting Storms' clothes on fire. Short shot Storms again before his body hit the ground.^[46] George Parsons witnessed Storms' death and wrote in his journal, "The faro games went right on as though nothing had happened.^[47]" Short was arrested but the shooting was ruled as self defense. Short left Tombstone in April and returned to Leadville, Colorado.^[46]

The Tombstone Daily Journal asked in March 1881 how a hundred outlaws could terrorize the best system of government in the world, asking, "Can not the marshal summon a posse and throw the ruffians out?"^[48]:119

Billy Claiborne shoots James Hickey

In Charleston on October 1, 1881, James Hickey was drunk. He taunted Billy Claiborne, following him around, daring him to fight. Billy avoided Hickey and left Ben Wood's Saloon for J.B. Ayer's Saloon across the street. Hickey followed right behind, hectoring Claiborne. Claiborne left once again because of Hickey and headed toward Harry Queen's Saloon.^[41] Hickey stopped him before he could enter Harry Queen's. Claiborne yelled, "Stay away from me!" and drew his revolver. He shot Hickey once between the eyes. Claiborne was arrested and stood trial but was acquitted because of Hickey's harassment.^[49]

Frank Leslie kills Billy Claiborne

On November 14, 1882, Frank Leslie became involved in an argument with Billy Claiborne who, after the recent death of William Bonney, had demanded to be known as "Billy the Kid". Claiborne claimed he had killed three men who had ridiculed him, although there is only evidence of Claiborne 's fight with Bill Hickey. But he had run from the Gunfight at the O.K. Corral, and his reputation suffered as a result.^[50] On this late night, Claiborne threatened Leslie. When Leslie still refused to refer to him as "Billy the Kid", Claiborne left, only to return later that night. A patron told Leslie that Claiborne was waiting for him outside the Oriental Saloon.^[50] Leslie walked out a side door and when Claiborne shot at him, he shot back, killing him. Because Claiborne was waiting outside to ambush Leslie and fired first, the killing was ruled justified. It was described as "an incident that became an open-and-closed affair over the short period of time required by Frank to puff through a rolled cylinder of Bull Durham."^[39]

Spurned lover kills William Kinsman

On February 23, 1883, William Kinsman had been living with May Woodman. Apparently as a joke, someone had run a notice in the Epitaph newspaper that Kinsman intended to marry Woodman. Kinsman responded and ran his own announcement that he had no intentions of marrying May Woodman. Kinsman was standing in front of the Oriental Saloon on Allen Street when May Woodman walked up and shot him. Woodman was sentenced to five years in the Yuma Territorial Prison for killing Kinsman, although the acting governor pardoned her after she had served less than one year.^[41]

Lester Moore no more

One of the most well-known headstones in Tombstone's Boot Hill cemetery belongs to Lester Moore. He was a Wells, Fargo & Co. station agent in the Mexican border at Naco, Arizona Territory. One afternoon Hank Dunstan appeared to claim a package due him. When he got it, he found it thoroughly mangled. The two men argued, and then both Moore and Dunstan drew their weapons. Dunstan got off four shots, hitting Moore in the chest with his .44 caliber revolver. Dunstan was mortally wounded with a hole through his ribs by the single shot Moore had squeezed off. Les Moore was buried in Boot Hill and his famous tombstone epitaph remains an attraction in the cemetery:^[41]

HERE LIES LESTER MOORE, FOUR SLUGS FROM A 44, NO LES NO MORE

Sheriff Slaughter vs Jack Taylor Gang

In 1886, John Slaughter was elected Cochise County sheriff. Four members of the Jack Taylor Gang—Manuel Robles, Geronimo Miranda, Fred Federico, and Nieves Deron—were wanted by both the Mexican Rurales and Arizona law enforcement for robbery and murder. Trying to evade the lawmen's pursuit, the men came to Tombstone to visit relatives. Slaughter heard that the men were nearby and rode out to arrest them, but the outlaws were tipped off and fled. Slaughter eventually learned they were hiding with Robles' brother in nearby Contention City. Slaughter raised a posse and raided the house. They surprised Robles and Deron while they were asleep, but the gang members rose shooting. Slaughter killed Robles' brother while Deron and Robles ran for cover. Shooting as he ran, Deron nicked Slaughter's right ear lobe. Slaughter shot back and mortally wounded Deron. In his dying minutes, Deron confessed he was guilty of the crimes he had been charged with. Robles got away but he and Miranda were later shot and killed by Mexican authorities.

Elections and ballot-stuffing

Democrat Charles A. Shibell

Republican Bob Paul

Pima County sheriff Democrat Charles A. Shibell appointed Wyatt Earp as a Pima County Deputy Sheriff on July 27, 1880.^[51] Wyatt did his job well, and from August through November his name was mentioned nearly every week by the Epitaph or the Nugget newspapers.^[52]

Pima County sheriff

Shibell ran for reelection in the November 2, 1880, against Republican Bob Paul. The region was strongly Republican^[53]:158 and Paul was expected to win. Whoever won would likely appoint someone from the same political party. Republican Wyatt expected he would continue in the job.

Johnny Ringo attended the Democratic party convention in Pima County and got himself elected as a delegate for San Simon/Cienega Precinct 27, located in San Simon Valley in northern Cochise County. This was despite the fact he'd shot Louis Hancock, the brother in law to James Hayes, a member of the Committee of Credentials, only a few months before. He persuaded the Pima County Board of Supervisors to make the house of rustling buddy Joe Hill the polling place and himself and Ike Clanton as election officials.^[24]:124 But when the supervisors learned that Joe Hill had already moved, they moved the polling place to the home of John Magill and removed Johnny Ringo and Ike Clanton as election officials, but it was too late.^[24]:125[54] On the day of the election in

James C. Hancock reported that Cowboys Curly Bill Brocius and Ringo served as election officials in the San Simon precinct.^[55] However, on June 1, the day before the election, Ringo biographer David Johnson places Ringo in New Mexico with Ike Clanton.^[56] Curly Bill had been arrested and jailed in Tucson on October 28 for killing Sheriff Fred White and he was still there on election day.^[54]

A mysterious "Henry Johnson" was responsible for certifying the ballots. This turned out to be James Johnson, the same James K. Johnson who had been shooting up Allen Street the night Marshal White was killed. Moreover, he was the same Johnson that testified at Curly Bill's preliminary hearing after he shot Fred White.^[55] James Johnson later testified for Bud Paul in the election hearing and said that the ballots had been left in the care of Phin Clanton. None of the witnesses during the election hearing reported on ballots being cast for dogs.^[54]

They gathered the dozen or so legal voters in town and coerced them to vote for Shibell. Then they gathered non-voters like the children and Chinese and had them cast ballots. Not satisfied, the named all the dogs, burros and poultry and cast ballots in their names for Shibell. The San Simon precinct turned out an amazing 104 votes, 103 of them for Shibell.^[57]

Democrat Shibell was unexpectedly reelected by a margin of 58 votes.^[55] He immediately appointed Johnny Behan as the new deputy sheriff for the Tombstone region of Pima County. Wyatt, also a Republican, supported Paul and resigned as deputy sheriff on November 9.^[58] Shibell immediately appointed Behan as the new South Pima deputy sheriff.^[59] Paul and Earp checked the ballots and were suspicious to see that 108 out of 109 voters in Precinct 27 had voted for Shibell.

On November 19, Paul filed suit and accused Shibell of ballot-stuffing. The trial was transferred to Tucson's district court and began in January 17. On January 20, 1881, the Arizona Star reported, “There has been some big cheating somewhere, and by some persons. It was clear that there had been reckless counting at Tombstone, fraud at San Simon and a careless election board at Tres Alamos.”^[55] A recount was held and this time Paul had 402 votes and Shibell had 354.

Judge Judge C.G.W. French ruled in Paul's favor in late January, 1881, throwing the whole precinct out,^[57] but Shibell appealed, preventing Paul from taking office until April 1881. However, the eastern portion of Pima County had been split off to form Cochise County on February 1. This prevented Paul from appointing Earp as deputy sheriff for the Tombstone area of Pima County.^[6]

Cochise County sheriff

When Cochise County was initially formed, both Wyatt Earp and Johnny Behan sought the new sheriff's position. It was a lucrative job, far beyond its salary. The sheriff was not only responsible for enforcing the law but was also county assessor, tax collector, and responsible for collecting prostitution, gambling, liquor, and theater fees. The county supervisors allowed the sheriff to keep ten percent of all amounts paid.^[53]:161:157 This made the job worth more than $40,000 a year (about $982,483 today).

Democrat Johnny Behan had considerably more political experience than Republican Wyatt Earp. Behan had previously served as Yavapai County Sheriff from 1871 to 1873. He had been elected to the Arizona Territorial Legislature twice, representing Yavapai Country in the 7th Territorial Legislature in 1873^[60]:511 and Mohave County in the 10th in 1879.^[60]:514 Behan moved for a time to the northwest Arizona Territory where he served as the Mohave County Recorder in 1877 and then deputy sheriff of Mohave County at Gillet, in 1879.

Furthermore, Behan's partner in the Dexter Livery, John Dunbar, had a brother Thomas who served in the Arizona Territorial Legislature. Thomas Dunbar introduced the bill that split Cochise County off from Pima County in the far southeast corner of the territory, and he became known as the “father of Cochise County”.^[61] The Dunbar family in their home town of Bangor, Maine, were "close family friends" of the powerful Senator James G. Blaine, also from Bangor, and one of the most powerful Republican congressmen of his time.^[53]:161 The Dunbars used their influence to help Behan get appointed Sheriff of the new Cochise County, in February 1881.^[62]:76

Behan utilized his existing position and his superior political connections to lobby hard for the position. The office was appointed by the Territorial governor and confirmed by the territorial legislature. Wyatt also had other interests including a claim in the Vizina mine, water rights proposals, and a one-quarter interest in the Oriental Hotel where the ran the Faro concession at the Oriental Saloon.^[63] Behan made a deal with Earp: he promised Wyatt a position as his undersheriff if he was appointed over Wyatt. Earp withdrew his name from the political contest. Behan used the influence Behan had previously served as Yavapai County Sheriff from 1871 to 1873. He had been elected to the Arizona Territorial Legislature twice, representing Yavapai Country in the 7th Territorial Legislature in 1873^[60]:511 and Mohave County in the 10th in 1879.^[60]:514 Behan moved for a time to the northwest Arizona Territory where he served as the Mohave County Recorder in 1877 and then deputy sheriff of Mohave County at Gillet, in 1879.

When Cochise County was formed, Governor John C. Frémont appointed and the Territorial Legislature approved Behan as Sheriff and John Dunbar as the first Cochise County Treasurer on February 10, 1881.^[64]

Behan reneged on his deal with Earp and appointed prominent Democrat Harry Woods instead. Later that year, Behan gave a contrived explanation of his actions during the hearings after the Gunfight at the O.K. Corral. He said he broke his promise to appoint Earp because of an incident shortly before his appointment. Searching for a horse stolen in late 1879, Wyatt learned about a year later that the horse was in nearby Charleston. Wyatt spotted Billy Clanton attempting to remove the horse from a corral and retrieved it without trouble.^[65] Behan was in the area to serve a subpoena on Ike Clanton. Ike was hopping mad when Behan finally found him, for Earp had told Clanton that Behan "had taken a posse of nine men down there to arrest him."^[66] Behan took offense at Wyatt's tactics and changed his mind about appointing Wyatt. Holliday reported in an interview in 1882 that "from that time a coolness grew up between the two men."^[67]:164

Virgil Earp loses election

Deputy U.S. Marshal Virgil Earp ran against Ben Sippy, a part-time policeman, for the job of Tombstone City Marshal. Sippy ran ads in the Democrat and Cowboy-loyal Nuggett, but Virgil didn't get the support he expected from John Clum and the Republican The Epitaph. To Virgil's surprise, he lost, by a margin of 311-259.

Stagecoach robberies

Between 1877 and 1882, bandits robbed 36 stagecoaches in the southern portion of the territory.^[68]

While the election was being contested, Bob Paul worked as a Wells Fargo shotgun messenger. On March 15, 1881, at 10 p.m., three cowboys attempted to rob a Kinnear & Company stagecoach carrying US$26,000 in silver bullion (or about $638,614 in today's dollars) near Benson. The stage was en route from Tombstone to Benson, Arizona, the nearest rail terminal.^[69]:180 Eli "Budd" Philpot, a popular driver, had been handling the reins but felt ill and switched gave Paul the driver's seat in Contention City. Near Drew's Station, just outside Contention City, a man stepped into the road and commanded them to "Hold!" Paul fired his shotgun and emptied his revolver at the robbers, wounding a Cowboy later identified as Bill Leonard in the groin. They returned fire, killing Philpot, sitting in Bob Paul's place. Paul urged the horses forward and the Cowboys fired again,^[70] killing Peter Roerig, a beer salesman for Anheuser Busch riding in the rear dickey seat.^[71] The horses spooked and Paul wasn't able to bring the stage under control for almost a mile, leaving the robbers with nothing. Paul later said he thought the first shot killing Philpot in the shotgun messenger seat had been meant for him as he would normally have been seated there.^[72][73]

Paul sent a telegram from nearby Benson to Deputy U.S. Marshal Virgil Earp. When Virgil received it at 10:00 pm, he deputized Wyatt and Morgan Earp, Bat Masterson, who was dealing faro at the Oriental Saloon, and Wells Fargo agent Marshall Williams. Pima County Sheriff Behan and Deputy Sheriff Billy Breakinridge joined in. They arrived at Drew's Station around dawn. Behan tried to talk them out of following the murders. The Earps were skilled trackers and Masterson could read sign like an Indian. Virgil insisted they pursue the killers and told Behan he could ride along or ride back to Tombstone. Behan indifferently agreed to stay, and they tracked three pairs of boots to a nearby hiding spot where the outlaws mounted their horses, accompanied by a fourth rider. Bob Paul thought he recognized the voices of Bill Leonard and Jim Crain. Wyatt had seen Cowboys who worked for the Clantons—Bill Leonard, Harry "The Kid" Head, Jim Crain and a drifter named Luther King—camped out in an old adobe along the stage route for the past week, and he suspected they were watching the stage for an opportunity to rob it.^[74]:201

The lines between the outlaw element and law enforcement were not always distinct. Doc Holliday had a reputation as a killer, though modern research has only identified three individuals he shot. He was friends with Bill Leonard, who was implicated in a stagecoach robbery. The Earp posse followed the robbers' trail to a nearby ranch where they found King. He wouldn't tell who his confederates were until the posse lied and told him that Holliday's girlfriend Big Nose Kate had been shot in the holdup. Fearful of Holliday's reputation, he confessed to holding the reins of the robbers' horses, and identified Leonard, Head, and Crain as the robbers.^[75]:181 They were all known Cowboys and rustlers. Behan, Breakinridge, and Williams escorted King back to Tombstone.^[74]

Posse tracks robbers

On March 19, King was escorted in the front door of the jail and let out the back a few minutes later. King had arranged with Undersheriff Harry Woods (publisher of the Nuggett) to sell the horse he had been riding to John Dunbar, Sheriff Behan's partner in the Dexter Livery Stable.^[67]:164 King conveniently escaped while Dunbar and Woods were making out the bill-of-sale. Woods claimed that someone had deliberately unlocked a secured back door to the jail.^[9] The Earps and the townspeople were furious at King's easy escape.^[72] Williams was later dismissed from Wells Fargo, leaving behind a number of debts, when it was determined he had been stealing from the company for years.^[75]

The Earps, Bob Paul, and others pursued the other two men for 17 days, riding at one point for 60 hours without food and 36 hours without water. The Cowboys were able to trade in their horses for fresh stock from friendly ranchers along the way. The lawmen were not so fortunate. During the ride Paul's horse died and Wyatt and Morgan's horses became so weak that the two men walked 18 miles (29 km) back to Tombstone to obtain new horses.^[76] After pursuing the Cowboys for over 400 miles (640 km) in a grand circle that finally led them into New Mexico, they could not obtain more fresh horses and were forced to give up the chase. They returned to Tombstone on April 1 to find that King had escaped.^[17]:123[77] Wyatt accused Behan of complicity in King's escape, a charge when Behan strongly denied.^[74]

Behan submitted a bill for $796.84 to the county for posse expenses, but he refused to reimburse the Earp's for any of their costs. Virgil was incensed. They were finally reimbursed by Wells, Fargo & Co. later on, but King's easy escape and Behan's refusal to reimburse them caused further friction between county and city law enforcement, and between Behan and the Earps.^[9]:38[78]

Bisbee stagecoach robbery

Virgil Earp was appointed Tombstone's city marshal (chief of police) on June 6, 1881, after Ben Sippy abandoned the job. On September 8, 1881, tensions between the Earps and the McLaurys further increased when a passenger stage on the 'Sandy Bob Line' in the Tombstone area bound for Bisbee, Arizona was held up. The masked bandits robbed all of the passengers of their valuables and the strongbox of about $2,500.^[15] During the robbery, the driver heard one of the robbers describe the money as "sugar", a phrase known to be used by Frank Stilwell. Stilwell had until the prior month been a deputy for Sheriff Behan but had been fired for "accounting irregularities".^[77]

Tom McLaury

Both Pete Spence and Stilwell were friends of Tom and Frank McLaury. Wyatt and Virgil Earp rode with the sheriff's posse attempting to track the Bisbee stage robbers. At the scene of the holdup, Wells, Fargo & Co. undercover agent Fred Dodge discovered an unusual boot print left by someone wearing a custom-repaired boot heel.^[77] The Earps checked a shoe repair shop in Bisbee that had removed a heel matching the boot print from Frank Stilwell's boot.^[77]

When Stilwell arrived in Bisbee with his livery stable partner, Pete Spence, Tombstone Marshal Virgil Earp and Tombstone Special Police Officer Wyatt Earp arrested them for the robbery. Stilwell and Spence were arraigned before Judge Wells Spicer and posted $7,000 bond.^[15] At the preliminary hearing, Stilwell and Spence were able to provide several witnesses who supported their alibis. Judge Spicer dropped the charges for insufficient evidence just as he had done for Doc Holliday earlier in the year.^[79] Having evaded the state charges, Virgil Earp in his other role as Deputy U.S. Marshal re-arrested Spence and Stilwell on October 13 for the Bisbee robbery on a new federal charge of interfering with a mail carrier.^[80] The newspapers, however, reported that they had been arrested for a different stage robbery that occurred (October 8) near Contention City. Virgil took Frank to Tucson for arraignment where he was held at the territorial jail. While Virgil was in Tucson, he deputized Wyatt to act in his place an assistant city marshal in Tombstone. The Cowboys saw the new arrest as further evidence they were being unfairly harassed and targeted by the Earps. They let the Earps know that they could expect retaliation.^[12] While Wyatt and Virgil were in Tucson for the federal hearing on the charges against Spence and Stilwell, Frank McLaury confronted Morgan Earp. He told him that the McLaurys would kill the Earps if they tried to arrest Spence, Stilwell, or the McLaurys again.^[66] The Tombstone Epitaph reported "that since the arrest of Spence and Stilwell, veiled threats [are] being made that the friends of the accused will 'get the Earps.'"^[81]:137

Prominent businessman murdered

Representing the danger of the Cowboys to the business owners and citizens, on Saturday, March 25, 1882, Martin R. Peel of the Tombstone Milling and Mining Company near Charleston was murdered by two masked men. They simply walked in on the mill superintendent, Peel, and a third man^[33]:361 and shot Peel through the heart at such close range that his clothing was set on fire. The others in the room with him when he was attacked fled. The person who discovered his body and extinguished the flames found him 30 minutes after the attack.^[82]

The crime sent reverberations through Tombstone and Cochise County. His father, respected Judge Bryant L. Peel, sent an open letter to The Tombstone Epitaph stating that the citizens needed to take the law into their own hands.^[18]:256[83]

Perhaps I am not in a condition to express a clear, deliberate opinion, but I would say to the good citizens of Cochise County there is three things you have to do. There is a class of cut-throats among you and you can never convict them in court. You must combine and protect yourselves and wipe them out, or you must give up the country to them, or you will be murdered one at a time, as my son has been. B. L. Peel.^[18]:137

Bisbee Massacre

On December 8, 1883 in Bisbee, Arizona five outlaw Cowboys robbed the Goldwater & Castaneda Mercantile and killed four people. Six men were arrested and five of them were later convicted and executed on March 28, 1884 for the crime. They were the first criminals to be legally hanged in Tombstone, then the county seat.^[84][85]

The sixth man, John Heath, who was accused of organizing the robbery, was tried separately and sentenced to life in prison. Unsatisfied with what they perceived as a lenient sentence, a Tombstone lynch mob forcibly removed him from jail and hanged him on February 22, 1884. Today, the graves of the five murderers are part of the popular tourist attraction at Boothill Graveyard in Tombstone.^[86][87]

References

1. Edwards, Josh (May 2, 1980). "George Goodfellow's Medical Treatment of Stomach Wounds Became Legendary". The Prescott Courier. pp. 3–5.
2. "Fort Bowie National Historic Site". Archived from the original on June 6, 2012. Retrieved June 6, 2012.
3. "Soldiers vs. Apaches: One Last Time at Guadalupe Canyon". Wild West magazine. June 12, 2006. Archived from the original on June 6, 2012. Retrieved June 6, 2012.
4. "Apache Kid". American National Biography Online. February 2000. Archived from the original on June 6, 2012. Retrieved June 6, 2012.
5. "Arizona Cochise County Records".
6. "Cochise County Arizona". County Website. Cochise County. 2009. Retrieved 2009-09-25.
7. A Historical and Biographical Record of the Territory of Arizona. Chicago: McFarland and Poole. 1896. Retrieved 14 October 2014.
8. "The Battle of Apache Pass". DiscoverSEAZ. Archived from the original on June 6, 2012. Retrieved June 6, 2012.
9. Lubet, Steven (2004). Murder in Tombstone: the Forgotten Trial of Wyatt Earp. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press. p. 288. ISBN 978-0-300-11527-7. Retrieved 2011-04-14.
10. Swansburg, John (November–December 2004). "Wyatt Earp Takes the Stand". LegalAffairs.com.
11. Barra, Allen (2008). Inventing Wyatt Earp: His Life and Many Legends. Lincoln, Nebraska: University of Nebraska Press. p. 440. ISBN 978-0-8032-2058-4.
12. "Tensions Grow in Tombstone, Arizona, After a Stage Coach Robbery". History.com. Retrieved February 5, 2011.
13. Bishop, William Henry (1900) [1888]. Mexico, California and Arizona. New York and London: Harper and Brothers. p. 468. Archived from the original on 2007. Retrieved June 6, 2012.
14. "The O.K. Corral Documents". April 28, 2010. Retrieved February 11, 2011.
15. "Tombstones O.K. Corral 2". The Old West History Net. Archived from the original on June 16, 2011. Retrieved May 5, 2011.
16. "History of Old Tombstone". Discover Arizona. Retrieved 2011-02-07.
17. Ball, Larry Durwood. The United States Marshals of New Mexico and Arizona Territories, 1846 – 1912. University of New Mexico Press. p. 325. ISBN 978-0-8263-0617-3.
18. Roberts, Gary L. (2007). Doc Holliday: The Life and Legend. New York, NY: Wiley, J. ISBN 978-0-470-12822-0.
19. DeArment, Robert K. Bat Masterson: The Man and the Legend. University of Oklahoma Press. ISBN 978-0-8061-2221-2.
20. "Wyatt Earp's Vendetta Posse". HistoryNet.com. January 29, 2007. Retrieved February 18, 2011.
21. ODMP U.S. Deputy Marshals Finley
22. "Another Murder by the Earp Party". Sacramento Daily Union. 24 March 1882. Retrieved 2 October 2014.
23. Ball, Larry D. (Autumn 1973). "Pioneer Lawman: Crawley P. Dake and Law Enforcement on the Southwestern Frontier". The Journal of Arizona History. Arizona Historical Society. 14 (3): 243–256. JSTOR 41695121.
24. Guinn, Jeff. The Last Gunfight: The Real Story of the Shootout at the O.K. Corral and How it Changed the American West (First hardcover ed.). New York: Simon & Schuster. ISBN 978-1-4391-5424-3.
25. "Testimony of Sheriff John H. Behan". November 13–14, 1881. Retrieved January 13, 2011.
26. "Drew's Station". Wyatt Earp Explorers. Retrieved February 11, 2011.
27. Burnham, Frederick Russell (1926). Scouting on Two Continents. Garden City, New York: Doubleday. pp. 28–35. ISBN 978-1-879356-31-3.
28. Monahan, Sherry A. (2007). Tombstone's Treasure: Silver Mines and Golden Saloons. Albuquerque, New Mexico: University of New Mexico Press. p. 168. ISBN 978-0-826341-76-1. OCLC 76897621.
29. "Assassination". Sacramento daily record-union. Sacramento, California. August 15, 1884.
30. Tefertiller, Casey; Morey, Jeff. "O.K. Corral: A Gunfight Shrouded in Mystery". Retrieved 11 November 2015.
31. Casey Tefertiller (1997). Wyatt Earp: The Life Behind the Legend. New York: John Wiley & Sons. ISBN 0-471-18967-7.
32. "Skeleton Canyon". Ghost Towns of Arizona. Retrieved 2011-02-07.
33. Paula Mitchell Marks (1989). And Die in the West: the Story of the O.K. Corral Gunfight. New York: Morrow. ISBN 0-671-70614-4.
34. "Doc Holliday". Outlaws & Gunslingers Legends. Retrieved 2011-02-07.
35. Flood, John H. (1926). Flood Manuscript (Unpublished manuscript ed.). p. 85.
36. "Wyatt Earp History Page". Retrieved April 11, 2011.
37. Linder, Douglas, ed. (2005). "Testimony of Virgil Earp in the Preliminary Hearing in the Earp Case". Famous Trials: The O. K. Corral Trial. Retrieved February 6, 2011.
38. Nation, Earl F. (September 1980). "The Terrors of Tombstone as Seen First-Hand" (PDF). The Branding Iron (140): 1, 5–7. Retrieved 24 March 2015.
39. Booth, Ken. "Tracking Buckskin Frank from Tombstone to Yuma". Retrieved May 6, 2011.
40. ""Buckskin Frank" Leslie". Outlaws and Gunslingers. Retrieved May 6, 2011.
41. "Tombstone's Cemetery: Boothill". History Magazine. June 12, 2006. Retrieved May 6, 2011.
42. "Tombstone Pioneers Burial Places". Retrieved May 6, 2011.
43. "Tombstone Historical Text". Legends of America. Retrieved 24 March 2015.
44. Coke, Tom S. (2001). "Losing Gambler". Archived from the original on April 12, 2005. Retrieved May 22, 2011.
45. Woog, Adam (February 28, 2010). Wyatt Earp. Chelsea House Publications. ISBN 1-60413-597-2.
46. Wood, Bob. "Luke L. Short". Retrieved April 15, 2011.
47. Benford, Sally. "Easy Money". Arizona Highways. Retrieved April 15, 2011.
48. Ball, Larry D. (1999). The United States Marshals of New Mexico and Arizona Territories, 1846 – 1912. Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press. ISBN 978-0-8263-0617-3.
49. "Tombstone's Cemetery: Boothill". History Magazine. June 12, 2006. Retrieved May 6, 2011.
50. Hind, Andrew. "Buckskin Frank Leslie: The Tombstone Connection". Retrieved May 6, 2011.
51. Gatto, Steve. "Wyatt Earp History Page". WyattEarp.net. Retrieved May 5, 2011.
52. Gatto, Steve. "Wyatt Earp History Page". WyattEarp.net.
53. Breakenridge, William M. (1992). Brown, Richard Maxwell, ed. Helldorado: Bringing the Law to the Mesquite. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press. p. 448. ISBN 978-0-8032-6100-6. Retrieved 2011-04-14.
54. Johnson, David (1996). John Ringo (first ed.). Stillwater, OK: Barbed Wire Press. ISBN 978-0-935269-23-9.
55. Traywick, Ben. "Wyatt Earp's Thirteen Dead Men". Retrieved May 5, 2011.
56. Johnson, David (1996). John Ringo (First ed.). Stillwater, OK: Barbed Wire Press. ISBN 978-0-935269-23-9.
57. "Wyatt Earp vs. Curly Bill". Retrieved May 5, 2011.
58. "Resignation of the Office of Deputy Sheriff of Pima County". November 9, 1880. Retrieved March 7, 2011.
59. "Wyatt Earp". Retrieved April 11, 2011.
60. Wagoner, Jay J. (1970). Arizona Territory 1863 – 1912: A Political history. Tucson: University of Arizona Press. ISBN 0-8165-0176-9.
61. Smith, Monica Dunbar. "Dunbar's of Arizona". Retrieved June 11, 2011.
62. Brown, Richard Maxwell (1994). No Duty to Retreat: Violence and Values in American History and Society (first ed.). Norman, OK.: University of Oklahoma Press. ISBN 978-0-8061-2618-0.
63. "Tombstone, Arizona – The Gunfight at the O.K. Corral". Retrieved 2011-02-08.
64. "John Orlando Dunbar". Cochise County, Arizona. Retrieved June 11, 2011.
65. "The Life and Times of Billy Clanton 1862 – 1881". Retrieved March 11, 2011.
66. Douglas Linder (2005). "Testimony of Wyatt S. Earp in the Preliminary Hearing in the Earp-Holliday Case". Famous Trials: The O. K. Corral Trial. Retrieved 2011-02-06.
67. Jahns, Patricia (1998). The Frontier World of Doc Holliday. Lincoln, NB: University of Nebraska Press. p. 305. ISBN 978-0-8032-7608-6. Retrieved 2011-04-14.
68. Turk, David S. (May 2006). "U.S. Marshals Service Celebrates a Legacy of Cooperation". The Police Chief.
69. O'Neal, Bill (1979). Encyclopedia of Western Gunfighters. Norman, OK: University of Oklahoma Press. ISBN 978-0-8061-2335-6. Retrieved 2011-04-14.
70. Willis, W.F. "Tombstone, AZ". Retrieved May 17, 2011.
71. Reilly, Joe. "Born To Uphold The Law: Frank Sulloway's Principles Applied To the Earp-Clanton Feud of 1879 – 1882" (PDF). Drexel E-Repository and Archive. Archived from the original (PDF) on July 12, 2007. Retrieved June 6, 2011.
72. "Wyatt Earp Trial: 1881—A Mysterious Stage Coach Robbery—Clanton, Holliday, Told, Leonard, Doc, and Ike". Retrieved 2011-02-08.
73. "History Raiders". Retrieved February 11, 2011.
74. DeArment, Robert K. (1989). Bat Masterson: the Man and the Legend (Paperback ed.). Norman: University of Oklahoma Press. ISBN 978-0-8061-2221-2.
75. Weir, William (2009). History's Greatest Lies: the Startling Truths Behind World Events our History Books Got Wrong. Beverly, MA: Fair Winds Press. p. 288. ISBN 1-59233-336-2.
76. WGBH American Experience: Wyatt Earp, Complete Program Transcript. January 25, 2010.
77. "The McLaury Brother's Tombstone Story pt.II". Archived from the original on November 27, 2014. Retrieved February 12, 2011.
78. ""Arizona Affairs" An Interview With Virgil W. Earp – Tombstone History Archives". Real West Magazine. January 1982. originally published by the San Francisco Examiner on May 28, 1882
79. "Decision of Judge Wells Spicer after the Preliminary Hearing in the Earp-Holliday Case". November 30, 1881. Retrieved April 17, 2011.
80. Holliday Tanner, Karen; Dearment, Robert K. (2001). Doc Holliday: a Family Portrait. Norman: Univ of Oklahoma Press. ISBN 978-0-8061-3320-1.
81. Rosen, Fred (June 30, 2005). The Historical Atlas of American Crime. New York: Facts on File. p. 298. ISBN 978-0-8160-4841-0.
82. "Story of Phin Clanton". Phoenix, Arizona: Arizona Republican. March 3, 1898. p. 4.
83. "Weekly Citizen". Tucson, Arizona Territory: Arizona Weekly Citizen. April 2, 1882. p. 4.
84. The Tombstone Epitaph 12 February 1884
85. The Tombstone Republican. 16 February 1884
86. Weiser, Kathy (2013). "John Heath and the Bisbee Massacre". Legends of America website. Retrieved 5 June 2012.
87. "Five Murderers Suspended from One Beam at Tombstone Arizona/ A Riot as a side show". Tombstone Epitaph. Genealogy Trails website. 29 March 1884. Retrieved 18 August 2014.