Christchurch South by-election, 1939

Christchurch South by-election, 1939

3 June 1939

Turnout 11,905 (76.36%)   Candidate Robert Macfarlane Melville Lyons Party Labour National Popular vote 7,900 4,005 Percentage 66.36% 33.64%

MP before election Ted Howard Labour Elected MP Robert Macfarlane Labour

The 1939 Christchurch South by-election held on 3 June was caused by the death of Ted Howard during the term of the 26th New Zealand Parliament. The by-election in the Christchurch South electorate was contested by Robert Macfarlane for Labour and Melville Lyons for National, with Macfarlane winning the election. At the time, Macfarlane was Mayor of Christchurch.

Background

Since the first election of Ted Howard in the 1919 general election, Christchurch South was held by the Labour Party.^[1] At the last general election in 1938, Howard had polled 9,885 votes versus 3,890 votes for Gladstone Ward, the son of former Prime Minister Joseph Ward.^[1][2] When Howard died on 26 April 1939,^[3] the electorate was thus regarded as a safe seat for Labour.^[1]

On nomination day, two candidates were put forward: Robert Macfarlane for the Labour Party and Melville Lyons for the National Party.^[4] Mabel Howard, Ted Howard's daughter, had hoped to be put forward by the Labour Party, and she was endorsed by the local branch of the party.^[5] The national executive of the Labour Party chose Macfarlane, and Howard believed that she was opposed by the party's hierarchy due to her connections to John A. Lee, who was seen as a radical within the party.^[6] The chosen candidate, Macfarlane, had been Mayor of Christchurch since the previous year.^[7]

Results

Results of the Christchurch South general election held on 15 October 1938 were:^[2]

Christchurch South general election, 1938

Party		Candidate	Votes	%	±
	Labour	Ted Howard	9,885	71.76
	National	Gladstone Ward	3,890	28.24
Majority			5,995	43.52
Turnout			13,775

Results of the by-election held on 3 June 1939 were:^[8]

Christchurch South by-election, 1939

Party		Candidate	Votes	%	±
	Labour	Robert Macfarlane	7,900	66.36
	National	Melville Lyons	4,005	33.64
Majority			3,895	32.72	-10.80
Turnout			11,905	76.36[9]

There were 20 polling booths and Lyons obtained a majority at only two of those (at Kilmore Street and at the Provincial Chambers in Durham Street). Macfarlane could increase the Labour vote at one polling booth only (Antigua Street in Sydenham).^[10] Macfarlane stated that in his belief, about 2,000 Labour Party supporters did not vote because the outcome of the election was a foregone conclusion.^[11] This view was disputed in an editorial by The Evening Post, arguing that the reduced Labour support is due to Howard's popularity that Macfarlane does not possess despite many high-profile politicians having campaigned on Labour's behalf, and that it is more likely that National supporters have suffered from apathy, as Lyons never had any hope of winning the election.^[12]

Macfarlane held the electorate until its abolition at the 1946 general election and subsequently Christchurch Central^[13] until the 1969 general election, when he retired.

Notes

1. "The By-Election". Evening Post. CXXVII (128). 2 June 1939. p. 8. Retrieved 13 November 2011.
2. "General Election". The Evening Post. CXXVI (98). 22 October 1938. p. 10. Retrieved 14 November 2011.
3. Scholefield 1950, p. 115.
4. "City By-Election". The Evening Post. CXXVII (118). 22 May 1939. p. 11. Retrieved 14 November 2011.
5. "Labour Party Nomination". The Evening Post. CXXVII (102). 3 May 1939. p. 7. Retrieved 14 November 2011.
6. McAloon, Jim. "Howard, Mabel Bowden". Dictionary of New Zealand Biography. Ministry for Culture and Heritage. Retrieved 15 November 2011.
7. "Chairmen and mayors". Christchurch: Christchurch City Council. Archived from the original on 22 May 2010. Retrieved 15 November 2011.
8. "Official Count". The Evening Post. CXXVII (134). 9 June 1939. p. 6. Retrieved 14 November 2011.
9. "By-Election Result". Rodney and Otamatea Times, Waitemata and Kaipara Gazette. 7 June 1939. p. 5. Retrieved 14 November 2011.
10. "Seat Retained". Evening Post. CXXVII (130). 5 June 1939. p. 10. Retrieved 14 November 2011.
11. "A Hard Fight". Evening Post. CXXVII (130). 5 June 1939. p. 10. Retrieved 14 November 2011.
12. "A Straw Vote". The Evening Post. CXXVII (130). 5 June 1939. p. 8. Retrieved 14 November 2011.
13. Scholefield 1950, p. 122.

References

• New Zealand Official Yearbook 1940 p926
• Scholefield, Guy (1950) [First published in 1913]. New Zealand Parliamentary Record, 1840–1949 (3rd ed.). Wellington: Govt. Printer.